Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental TestingMiner, James Burt
Science
Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental Testing
Miner, James Burt
Children with mental disabilities; Juvenile delinquents; Mentally ill offenders; Psychological tests
The practical consideration of these borderlines in Part One and their
location on the test scale emphasizes that a test diagnosis is only
symptomatic, that the suggested borderlines on the Binet scale are
determined from limited data which may not be verified in other
communities, that the scale itself is imperfect, and that the results
should be checked by other tests, especially by the school retardation,
a new example of which is given for the Minneapolis delinquents. The
plan of the percentage method of describing the borderlines readily
allows for adjustment to more complete data or better developmental
scales. The alternative to the use of a test record as symptomatic of
deficiency is dependence upon the history of the case or physical signs,
such as are found among Mongolians, cretins, epileptics, etc. These
signs have been found among only about 13% of the deficient children
(_141_). Expert opinion given on the history of the case is clearly less
reliable than such opinion checked by even a crude objective test
standard. In Part Two of this study the theoretical background for the
percentage definition is compared with that of other quantitative
definitions on the basis of the conceptions of mental measurement and
mental development.
3. In attempting to suggest methods for diagnosis and control, which our
summary of the scientific data makes necessary, we shall be led beyond
the evidence presented in this study. To those to whom these suggestions
may seem remoted from the foregoing pages, it may be said that they are
the result not only of a review of the available research work, but also
an outcome of several years observation of the practical handling of
this problem both in this country and abroad. In that study I was led to
visit several scores of institutions and schools for delinquent or
deficient children in Austria, England, France, Germany, Italy and
Switzerland. The methods suggested below for the case of the deficient
delinquent are only modifications of what has been observed in actual
operation.
An adequate diagnosis of deficiency involves not only the accurate
knowledge of the present mental condition of the individual, but an
understanding of the causes of that condition. This requires a complete
family and social history of the individual and a knowledge of the
medically removable handicaps. It would seem, therefore, that such a
diagnosis may be best made by a commission which shall include a
physician as well as a psychologist, or else by an _expert in mental
development_ who is provided with adequate facilities and assistance for
discovering other handicaps than innate incapacity. For the group of
uncertain and conative cases a final diagnosis should, if possible, be
made only after prolonged observation in a temporary home school.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account