Definitions in Political Economy,: Preceded by an Inquiry Into the Rules which Ought to Guide Political Economists in the Definition and Use of Their Terms; with Remarks on the Deviation from These Rules in Their WritingsMalthus, T. R. (Thomas Robert)
General
Definitions in Political Economy,: Preceded by an Inquiry Into the Rules which Ought to Guide Political Economists in the Definition and Use of Their Terms; with Remarks on the Deviation from These Rules in Their Writings
Malthus, T. R. (Thomas Robert)
Classical school of economics; Economics
Dissertation on Value, c. vii. p. 140.
Footnote 79:
Dissertation on Value, c. vi. p. 145.
Footnote 80:
It has always been a matter of great surprise to me that I should have
been accused of _arbitrarily_ adopting labour as the measure of value.
If there be not a most marked and characteristic distinction between
labour and any _product_ of labour, I do not know where a
characteristic distinction between two objects is to be found; and
surely I have stated this distinction often enough, and brought
forward the peculiar qualities of labour as my reasons for thinking
that it may be taken as a measure of value. Opinions may differ as to
the sufficiency of these reasons, or as to the degree of accuracy with
which it will serve the purpose of a measure. But how it can be said
that I have adopted it arbitrarily, is quite unintelligible to me. If
I had merely stated, that I had adopted it because it was the main
element in the natural costs of production, there could have been no
ground for such a charge.
Footnote 81:
Dissertation on Value, c. vii. p. 148.
Footnote 82:
Dissertation on Value, c. vii. p. 150.
Footnote 83:
On the Production of Wealth, c. i. p. 56.
Footnote 84:
I am very ready to include myself among those political economists who
have not been sufficiently attentive to this subject.
Footnote 85:
If in a foreign country, in which the relation of money to men and
labour was unknown to us, we were told that a quarter of corn was
selling for four ounces of silver, we should not know whether there
was a famine, and corn was held in the highest estimation, or whether
there was a glut of corn, and it was held in the lowest estimation.
The very term estimation, as applied to commodities, must of necessity
refer to man and labour.
Footnote 86:
It is a truth fruitful in important consequences, that the labour
which commodities will command when in their natural state, by
representing accurately the quantity of labour and profits necessary
to produce them, must represent accurately the effectual demand for
them. And this holds good at different places and times, referring of
course to the labour of the same description at each place and time.
Footnote 87:
What could give us any information respecting the scarcity of a
commodity in China, or the state of its supply as compared with the
demand, but a reference to Chinese labour?
Footnote 88:
Principles of Polit. Econ., c. i. s. i. p. 5. 3d edit.
Footnote 89:
M. Say’s comprehensive expression, “_Services productifs_,” includes
profits and rents as well as labour; but it is certain that labour
will measure accurately the value of the whole amount of these
services.
Footnote 90:
If this concession be once made, the whole question respecting labour
as a measure of value is at once decided.
Footnote 91:
C. xi. p. 232.
Footnote 92:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account