[54] Edinburgh Review, Vol. III. P. 55. _et seq._ [55] Gray's life. [56] Ibid. [57] Ibid. [58] Life of Pope. [59] Gray's life. [60] Ibid. [61] Gray's life. [62] Ibid. [63] Pastor cum traheret per freta navibus, &c. [64] Gray's life. Dr. Beattie of Aberdeen differs very widely from Dr. Johnson on the merit of this poem. He says, 'I have heard the finest Ode in the world (meaning Gray's Bard) blamed for the boldness of its figures, and for what the critic was pleased to call obscurity.' Beattie's Essays on poetry and musick, 3d edit. p. 269. This is, certainly very strong; yet he seems in some danger of contradicting himself, when he says in another place, That 'for energy of words, vivacity of description, and _apposite_ variety of numbers, Dryden's Feast of Alexander is superior to any ode of Horace or Pindar now extant.' Ibid, p. 17. One would have been apt to suppose that the Lyrick Poem which eclipsed Horace, if not the finest, is at least one of 'the finest in the world.'--But an author has novelty to recommend him, when he affirms that Gray is superior to Dryden, and Dryden to all Antiquity. [65] Gray's life. [66] Ibid. [67] Ibid. [68] Gray's life. [69] Gray's life. [70] A favourite phrase of the Rambler's. [71] Gray's life. [72] Ibid. [73] Taxation no Tyranny. [74] Taxation no Tyranny. [75] Dryden's life. [76] Ibid. [77] Rambler, No. 150. [78] Rambler, No. 9. [79] Vide the life of Garrick by Mr Davies. [80] Rambler, No. 160. [81] Ibid. [82] Churchill's Apology. [83] Vide Life of Cowley. His impressions had been very slight, for Crowley has nothing of the melody, or magnificence of the Fairy Queen. Of its great author we know little but that he was praised, and neglected, unfortunate, and poor: and, from his epitaph, that he died young. His subject is not happy, his words are often obsolete, and his stanza can hardly please us long. But we may presume that he wanted leisure to study the great models of antiquity: That he wanted that tranquillity of mind so requisite to the success of a poet: And that his defects are owing to the bad taste of his age, and the hardships of his life. Had he lived longer, and had he enjoyed that competence which a prudent shoeblack seldom fails to enjoy, Spenser would have been second in fame to Shakespeare only. [84] Dr Johnson on Cymbeline. The same sentiment is started in his account of Pope, 'To the particular species of excellence men are directed, not by an ascendant planet, or predominant humour, but by the first book which they read, some early conversation which they heard, or some accident which excited ardour and emulation.'--The Doctor is in this passage censuring Pope's ignorance of human nature--while his own marvellous and extreme stupidity makes him almost beneath censure. The reader will not realize Montesquieu's remark, That _when we attempt to prove things so evident we are sure never to convince_.