"_Abbot._ 'I have sixty-two monks at home, but you will never
find a book in my chamber.' _Magdalia._ 'That's a fine lookout
for your monks.' _Ab._ 'I can stand books, but not Latin ones.'
_Mag._ 'Why so?' _Ab._ 'Because that tongue is not suited to
women.' _Mag._ 'I should like to know why.' _Ab._ 'Because it
is far from helpful in maintaining their purity.' _Mag._ 'Do
those French books, then, full of idle tales, make for purity?'
_Ab._ 'Then there is another thing.' _Mag._ 'Well, out with it,
whatever it is.' _Ab._ 'They are safer from the priests if they
know no Latin.' _Mag._ 'Oh! but there is least danger of all
from that quarter according to your practice, for you do all you
can to keep from knowing Latin.' _Ab._ 'People in general are of
my mind because it is such a rare and unusual thing for a woman
to know Latin.' _Mag._ 'Don't talk to me of the people, the very
worst source of good actions--nor of custom, the mistress of all
evils. Let us accustom ourselves to what is good, then what was
formerly unusual will become usual, what was rude will become
polished, and what was unbecoming will grow to be fitting.'
... _Mag._ 'What think you of the Virgin Mother?' _Ab._ 'Most
highly.' _Mag._ 'Was she not versed in books?' _Ab._ 'Quite so,
but not in these books.' _Mag._ 'What, then, did she use to
read?' _Ab._ 'The Canonical Hours.' _Mag._ 'According to what
form?' _Ab._ 'That of the Benedictine order.'"
The Youth and the Harlot brings us to perhaps the best illustration
of that freedom of language which was the most common charge against
the Colloquies. The argument is one employed previously by the Saxon
nun Roswitha in the tenth century in her comedy _Paphnutius_. An
edition of Roswitha had been published at Nuremberg in 1501, so that
Erasmus may well have taken his model at first-hand. The conversation
is of the slipperiest, and yet the impression conveyed is not that
of immoral or even of unmoral writing. It is simply the baldest
"realism" of treatment, and the issue is distinctly a moral one. As
in Roswitha the erring woman is won to virtue by the Christian faith,
so here she is reformed by arguments of a more practical sort. The
dig at the monks is not lacking. The youth has been on a journey to
Rome:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account