Discourses on the First Decade of Titus LiviusMachiavelli, Niccolò
Philosophy
Discourses on the First Decade of Titus Livius
Machiavelli, Niccolò
Livy. Ab urbe condita; Political science -- Early works to 1800; Rome -- Historiography
Looking, therefore, to the course followed by the Romans in this
particular, and to that adopted by our modern rulers, it seems proper
to consider whether or not it is advisable to build fortresses, and
whether they are more likely to help or to hurt him who builds them In
the first place, then, we are to remember that fortresses are built
either as a defence against foreign foes or against subjects In the
former case, I pronounce them unnecessary, in the latter mischievous.
And to state the reasons why in the latter case they are mischievous, I
say that when princes or republics are afraid of their subjects and in
fear lest they rebel, this must proceed from knowing that their
subjects hate them, which hatred in its turn results from their own ill
conduct, and that again from their thinking themselves able to rule
their subjects by mere force, or from their governing with little
prudence. Now one of the causes which lead them to suppose that they
can rule by mere force, is this very circumstance of their people
having these fortresses on their backs So that the conduct which breeds
hatred is itself mainly occasioned by these princes or republics being
possessed of fortresses, which, if this be true, are really far more
hurtful than useful First, because, as has been said already, they
render a ruler bolder and more violent in his bearing towards his
subjects, and, next, because they do not in reality afford him that
security which he believes them to give For all those methods of
violence and coercion which may be used to keep a people under, resolve
themselves into two; since either like the Romans you must always have
it in your power to bring a strong army into the field, or else you
must dissipate, destroy, and disunite the subject people, and so divide
and scatter them that they can never again combine to injure you For
should you merely strip them of their wealth, _spoliatis arma
supersunt_, arms still remain to them, or if you deprive them of their
weapons, _furor arma ministrat_, rage will supply them, if you put
their chiefs to death and continue to maltreat the rest, heads will
renew themselves like those Hydra; while, if you build fortresses,
these may serve in time of peace to make you bolder in outraging your
subjects, but in time of war they will prove wholly useless, since they
will be attacked at once by foes both foreign and domestic, whom
together it will be impossible for you to resist. And if ever
fortresses were useless they are so at the present day, by reason of
the invention of artillery, against the fury of which, as I have shown
already, a petty fortress which affords no room for retreat behind
fresh works, cannot be defended.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account