Dissertations on the English Language, with Notes, Historical and Critical;: to Which is Added, by Way of Appendix, an Essay on a Reformed Mode of Spelling, With Dr. Franklin's Arguments on that SubjectWebster, Noah
General
Dissertations on the English Language, with Notes, Historical and Critical;: to Which is Added, by Way of Appendix, an Essay on a Reformed Mode of Spelling, With Dr. Franklin's Arguments on that Subject
Webster, Noah
English language -- Early works to 1800; English language -- Grammar -- Early works to 1800; Spelling reform -- Early works to 1800
"Suppose I were to say, that to every art there _was_ a system of such
various and well approved principles."----Harris.
The first part of the sentence is hypothetical, _suppose I were to
say_; but the last becomes declaratory under the supposition, and
therefore the form of the verb should be changed to the present,
indicative, _that to every art there is a system_: For it must be
remarked that when the English speak of general existence, they use the
present time; as, truth _is_ great above all things; the scriptures
_are_ a rule of faith; the heavens _display_ the glory of the Lord. The
past or the future, in such cases, would be highly improper. Hence the
absurdity of the passage just quoted; the supposition is that every art
_has_ (generally--at all times) a system of principles.
"If the taxes laid by government _were_ the only ones we _had_ to pay."
The author's meaning is, "the only taxes we _have_ to pay;" and he
was probably led into the mistake by not understanding the preceding
hypothetical verb, _were_, which actually speaks of the present time
conditionally.
The error will be more striking in the following passages.
"If an atheist would well consider the arguments in this book, he would
confess there _was_ a God."
There _was_ a God! And why not confess that there _is_ a God? The
writer did not consider that the first part of the sentence is
_conditional_, and that the last ought to be _declaratory_ of a fact
always existing.
"Two young men have made a discovery that there _was_ a God."----
Swift's Arg. against Abolishing Christianity.
A curious discovery indeed! Were the Dean still alive, he might find
there _is_ a great inaccuracy in that passage of his works.
"Yet were we to use the same word, where the figure _was_ manifest, we
should use the preposition _from_."----Priestley, Gram. p. 158.
Here is the same error, and the author may live to correct it.
But of all this class of mistakes, the following is the most palpable.
"I am determined to live, as if there _was_ a _future_ life."----
Hammon, quoted by Price and Priestley.
Hammon is an atheist, and it would require the same abilities to
reconcile the two words _was future_, as to reconcile his principles
with the common sense of mankind.[121]
The following passage, from _Gregory's Comparative View of the State
and Faculties of Man_, is remarkable for this error.
"Men have been taught that they _did_ (do) God acceptable service,
by abstracting themselves from all the duties they _owed_ (owe) to
society; and by inflicting on themselves the severest tortures which
nature can support. They have been taught that it _was_ (is) their
duty," &c.
"And yet one would think that this _was_ the principal use of the study
of history."----Bolingbroke on Hist. letter 3.
A similar fault occurs in one of Mrs. Thale's letters to Dr. Johnson,
Aug. 9, 1775.
"--Yet I have always found the best supplement for talk _was_ writing."
So in Blackstone's Commentaries, book 1. chap. 7.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account