Diversions of a NaturalistLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
Diversions of a Naturalist
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history
Old writers before the days of Darwin had talked and written about
the "missing link," though I cannot say who first used the term in
reference to a creature intermediate between man and apes. Sir Charles
Lyell in 1851 made use of the term in regard to extinct animals which
were intermediate in structure between two existing types. A learned
and able writer--the Scotch judge, Lord Monboddo--in the later half
of the eighteenth century put forward a theory of the development of
mankind from apes such as the orang, quite independently of any general
theory of "transformism" or of the progressive development of the
animal and vegetable worlds, from simple beginnings. Lord Monboddo,
in the absence of any knowledge of a "missing link," or of animals
intermediate between man and the highest living apes, made reasonable
speculations (based on wide study of anthropology and ancient
philosophy) as to the passage from the monkey to man. He regarded man
as of the same "species" as the orang-utan. He traced the gradual
elevation of man to the social state as a natural process determined
by "the necessities of human life." He looked on language (which he
said is not "natural" to man in the sense of being necessary to his
self-preservation) as a consequence of his social state. His views
about the origin of society and language, and the faculties by which
man is distinguished from the brutes, are in some interesting ways
similar to those of Darwin. He conceived man as gradually elevating
himself from an animal condition in which his mind is immersed in
matter to a state in which mind acts independent of body. He was
ridiculed and declared to be half mad by his co-temporaries (among them
Samuel Johnson), although he was, philosophically, far in advance of
those with whom he came into contact. Darwin's views on the "Descent of
Man" were met in the same contemptuous spirit at first. But he held a
much stronger position than Monboddo, having first of all established
the general theory of organic evolution, and having, further, a
well-established mass of evidence at his command in regard to the
relationship of man and apes. Further, he had that wonderful champion,
Huxley, to fight for him. Huxley's book, "Man's Place in Nature,"
originally given as lectures which I, then a boy, attended, placed the
evidence of the close relationship of man and the higher apes in the
clearest way before the public, and, indeed, established the identity
of the structure of man with that of the ape, bone for bone, muscle for
muscle, and nerve for nerve.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account