Diversions of a NaturalistLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
Diversions of a Naturalist
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history
The immense importance of the discovery of the jaw of Eoanthropus by
Mr. Dawson, and of the clear perception of its distinctive features
by Dr. Smith Woodward, is not, as yet, sufficiently recognized. The
Piltdown jaw is the most startling and significant fossil bone that
has ever been brought to light. The Neandermen and the Java skull-top
are simply commonplace and insignificant in comparison with it. "What
leads you to say that?" I may be asked. I say so because this jaw and
the incomplete skull found with it (Fig. 29) really and in simple fact
furnish a link--a form intermediate between the man and the ape. Some
fragments of the brain-case were found close to the jaw, indicating
a fairly round, very thick-walled brain-case, holding a brain of
about 1100 units capacity--very small for a man, very large for an
ape. It is in the highest degree probable that the brain-case and the
jaw belong to the same individual. If we were to put the brain-case
aside as not certainly belonging to the same individual, we should
guess that the owner of the jaw might have had a brain of about this
size--intermediate between that of the larger apes and the living races
of men.[11]
[11] The recent discovery by Mr. Dawson of fragments of a second skull
of the same character as the first and at the same spot justifies a
certain amount of hesitation in concluding that the lower jaw and the
fragments of the first found skull belong to one individual.
[Illustration: FIG. 25.--The Piltdown Jaw (shaded) and the Heidelberg
Jaw (outline only) super-imposed and compared by placing the first and
second molar teeth (1 and 2) of the two specimens in exact coincidence
on the horizontal line A, B. The linear dimensions of the drawings
are reduced to two-thirds of those of the specimens. It is obvious
that when the front bony part of the Piltdown jaw is completed with an
outline like that of the Heidelberg and Neander jaws, as shown by the
dotted line _m_, the space between its molars and the sockets of its
front teeth cannot be filled by teeth of the normal human dimensions,
as it is in the Heidelberg jaw. As the figure shows, they would stop
short half an inch from the front of the jaw. Hence Dr. Smith Woodward
inferred that larger teeth like those of a chimpanzee were present in
this region in the Piltdown jaw (Eoanthropus).]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account