Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
virtue even though it forces him to connive in predatory practices
of his concern. The class-conscious worker may be willing to disrupt
society in the interest of his class because all his moral needs are
satisfied by his devotion to what he regards as the most significant
social group. While this ethical paradox of patriotism is obviously
not confined to political groups, the nation is most seriously tempted
to unethical conduct because it is not a voluntary association, its
group is conveniently isolated from others and loyalty to it is least
qualified by other conflicting loyalties. It may be set down as a truth
of almost axiomatic finality, that groups tend to be unethical in
proportion to the degree of unqualified loyalty which they are able
to claim or exact of their members. In this connection it may be noted
that democracy has increased rather than diminished the imperialism
of nations, for it has given patriotism a higher moral sanction and
thus reduced the moral scruples which might qualify the loyalty of
their citizens. The arrogance of nations and their insistence on moral
autonomy has developed simultaneously with the extension of democracy.
It is this ethical paradox of patriotism which invalidates the
contention that the root of all imperialism is the imperialism of the
individual. It is true of course that group loyalty may become a device
for delegating our vices to the group and imagining ourselves virtuous.
Some types of political arrogance and race prejudice are obviously
methods of compensating individuals for their lack of opportunity
to bully their immediate neighbors. Yet on the whole the unethical
character of group action is determined as much by the partial virtues
as by the vices of individuals.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account