Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
The problem of bringing groups under some kind of ethical control is
not new in history. It has become unusually difficult in the modern
world not only because of the consolidation of the authority of the
state but also because rapid means of communication have increased the
size of social, political and economic units and made relations between
them more intricate. The larger the unit the more unqualified seems
to be the moral sanction which loyalty to it may claim. To an average
citizen, immersed in his parochial interests, the nation appears in the
light of a universal community in contrast to the smaller and voluntary
communities within the nation. Yet this same nation is one of many
human groups, most of which betray imperial desires reminiscent of Rome
but which aspire in vain after the universal dominion which gave Roman
imperialism a measure of moral worth. Treitschke, whose philosophy of
history was the object of so much opprobrium during the World War that
its faithfulness to the general prejudices of Western life would hardly
be surmised, presented the nation as the ultimate community because
all smaller societies are too petty to deserve and all larger ones too
vague and abstract to claim the unqualified allegiance of men.
The intricacies and propinquities of an industrial civilization tend at
some points to increase the imperial desires of nations and at others
to make their ordinary lusts more deadly. The feud between Germany
and France is a very ancient one, but the need of French industry
for German coal and of German industry for French iron explains some
aspects of their present difficulties which are not derived from
ancient animosities. Modern industry needs a unified world and, lacking
it, each nation is inclined to seek the completion of its industrial
establishment by the forcible appropriation of territory, rich in
needed resources. The economic imperialism of industrially advanced
nations is a product of the high productivity of modern industry which
produces more than one national unit can consume and which needs
more raw materials than the same nation can produce. Covetous eyes
are consequently turned upon undeveloped portions of the globe, rich
in raw materials and hungry for the products of modern industry. In
one sense the European war was incubated in Africa. Rapid means of
communication also extend the reach of the grasping nations. China is
attempting to throw off the shackles of a Western imperialism which
could never have gained the position it holds on Chinese soil but for
the new contiguity which has destroyed the boundaries between East and
West. Moreover, the intricacies of international commerce and finance
offer opportunities for a new kind of economic imperialism which hardly
needs, though it does not always avoid, the use of political force.
The economic forces of one nation simply penetrate the economic life
of another and, if there is a great disparity in economic power, the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account