Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
Though morally dependable action develops most readily in an atmosphere
of mutual trust, it is not to be assumed that either nations or
individuals always justify trust by trustworthy action. Faith does not
produce conscience automatically. Much of the pacifism now cultivated
by socially effective religious forces has the defect that it fails
to gauge the stubborn resistance to ideal forces in the predatory
nature of national groups. It is difficult to develop moral attitudes
sufficiently honest not only to give the bearer of trust the prestige
of sincerity but to make the object of trust worthy of its faith. Trust
united with selfishness results in moral futility; and when it is
based upon illusion and fails to take account of the imperfect social
attitudes which it must overcome, it issues in mere sentimentality. It
is significant that the idea of the outlawry of war should be espoused
particularly in America and find little favor in other nations; for
here extraordinary power is united with remarkable political naïvete,
so that American idealists find it difficult to appreciate the
unsatisfied hungers of other nations or their resentful reaction to our
own satiety. If nations cannot be moved to make some sacrifices for
the sake of the ideal and to qualify their expansive desires by moral
purpose, all efforts to create an international society must finally
prove vain. It may be that the secular ambitions of nations are so
firmly established in social custom and their unethical attitudes so
generally sanctioned by the popular mind that nothing will avail to
give their actions even a touch of ethical character. It is difficult
enough to subdue and discipline the immediate and anarchic desires
which struggle for expression in the soul of the individual; but when
they express themselves in the life of groups and are veiled in seeming
sanctities even while they achieve new and more diabolical forms they
can be subdued only by the most astute intelligence united with a high
moral passion. Modern civilization lacks both this intelligence and
this moral passion and is in the peril of losing what it has of the
latter as it develops the former. Moral idealism which fails to gauge
the measure of resistance which its ideals must meet in the confused
realities of life or to fashion adequate weapons for its conflict
degenerates into mere sentimentality. But a social intelligence which
is overwhelmed by the discouraging realities and despairs of the
attainment of any ideal sinks into a morally enervating cynicism. Moral
leadership in Western society is divided to-day between sentimentalists
and cynics who combine to render the prospect of an ethical
regeneration of modern life well-nigh hopeless. If men are really to be
redeemed from the sins of greed and mutual fears and hatreds by which
they make their common life intolerable they need a faith which is not
held too cheaply but which is held nevertheless in defiance of every
discouragement.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account