Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
The prospects for an exchange of values between the East and the West
are not particularly bright. The Orient is indeed being “Americanized,”
but partly through the policy of Western imperialism exploiting the
low living standards of Asia to the advantage of Western industry.
There is no powerful movement in the West to dissuade it from its
complete trust in physical power as the method of self-realization, and
in physical comfort as the way to happiness. Modern religion has not
been totally ineffective in qualifying racial arrogance and parochial
prejudices. But it has had practically no effect upon the instincts of
avarice which dominate Western life. The religious groups which are
still ambitious to defy civilization in the name of their faith have
a theology which cannot gain the respect of the thoughtful leaders of
modern life; and the sins of which they convict modern society are not
its real sins. The intellectually emancipated religious groups are too
thoroughly acclimatized to the atmosphere of Western life to have any
sensitiveness for its imperfections.
The greatest hope lies in the missionary enterprise, which through its
very effort toward the universalization of the Christian faith has
a tendency to strip it of its Occidental accretions, so that it may
become intrinsically worthy of its world expansion. The missionary
enterprise may thereby contribute as much toward the spiritualization
of Western life as toward the regeneration of the East. Its very
contact with the East gives it a perspective on the limitations of
Western life which churches at home do not possess. There is, of
course, the possibility that Western imperialism will so thoroughly
discredit the missionary enterprise before it can function in this
way that it will lose its whole prestige in the Eastern world. In
that case Japan will probably continue to unify and occidentalize
Asia in the hope of fighting fire with fire. A small minority of
thoughtful missionaries are making a desperate effort to disassociate
the missionary enterprise from the politics of Western imperialism in
the Orient. Considering the difficulty of their task, they have made
commendable progress. Yet if Christianity at home does not become
disassociated from and does not qualify the greed of which the Oriental
politics of Western nations is but one expression, the heroic efforts
of the missionaries may be vain. Men of prudence in the Orient may be
willing to concede that ideals have validity even if they are outraged
by those who ostensibly accept them. But the final test of ideals must
include their ability to qualify human action. If Christian idealism
is to be a force which will help to create a unified world culture,
capable of destroying the moral limitations of both the Oriental and
the Occidental strategy of life, it must detach itself more completely
from the temper of Western life even while it seeks to influence the
thought of the East.
CHAPTER VIII
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account