It is apparently a common belief in America that there are no
difficulties in domestic service in Europe, as it is an equally common
belief in Europe that the difficulties in domestic service are greater
in America than in any other country.[333] The judgment in one case
is as extreme as it is in the other. It is indeed as unsafe to make a
generalization in regard to all the phases of domestic service in Europe
as it is to make similar generalizations concerning all sections of
America—different countries have their own peculiar problems to meet,
and these vary in details as do the problems in different sections of
America. Yet a careful examination of the question may lead to the
conclusion that the differences in the condition of domestic service
in Europe and in America are those of degree rather than those of
fundamental principles; that the situation in Europe is modified rather
than radically altered by the social and political conditions existing
there; that as these conditions in Europe and in America become more
alike even these external differences will disappear, and that an ideal
form of domestic service exists as yet only in the castles of Spain.
Any consideration of domestic service as it is found in Europe to-day
must frankly recognize at the outset that the social and political
conditions that affect the question result on the one hand from tradition
and long-established customs, and on the other from the social and
political unrest that was born of the French Revolution. The past and
the present, the present and the future, stability and unrest, blind
obedience and personal freedom, aristocracy and democracy, have been
and are perpetually at war with each other. Every political revolution
that has widened the circle of democracy, every industrial movement that
has affected large classes of workers, every modification of national
ideals of education, every social change that has shifted the relations
of classes to each other, every barrier between nations that has been
broken down or that has been put up, has changed the problem of domestic
service. In England the tendencies towards social aristocracy on the one
hand and political democracy on the other, in Germany the trend towards
the exaction of military obedience in every walk in life and the counter
influences of the social democratic party, in France the deadening hand
of bureaucracy and the opposing unrestrained passions of the multitude,
in Italy the inherited prejudice against manual labor and the necessity
of gaining a livelihood by means of it,—all these forces so diametrically
opposed to each other, and so inevitably coming into collision, are but
illustrations of conflicting forces that have entered and that must
enter into the question. Political, industrial, educational, and social
changes have made England a manufacturing nation, have made Germany
one denominated by a military spirit and a military régime, have made
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account