Earl Hubert's Daughter: The Polishing of the Pearl - A Tale of the 13th CenturyHolt, Emily Sarah
General
Earl Hubert's Daughter: The Polishing of the Pearl - A Tale of the 13th Century
Holt, Emily Sarah
England -- Social life and customs -- 1066-1485 -- Fiction; Historical fiction
The disruption between the Greek and Latin Churches being now an
accomplished fact, the Archbishop of Antioch went the length of
excommunicating the Pope and the whole Roman Church, asserting that if
there were to be a supreme Pontiff, he had the better claim to the
title. This event caused a disruption on a small scale in Margaret's
bower, where Beatrice scandalised the fair community by wanting to know
why the Pope should not be excommunicated if he deserved it.
"Excommunicate the head of the Church!" said Hawise, in a horrified
tone.
"Well, but here are two Churches," persisted Beatrice. "If the Pope can
excommunicate the Archbishop, what is to prevent the Archbishop from
excommunicating the Pope?"
"Poor creature!" said Hawise pityingly.
"The Eastern schism is no Church!" added Eva.
"Oh, I do wish some of you would tell me what you mean by a Church!"
exclaimed Beatrice, earnestly, laying down her work. "What makes one
thing a Church, and another a schism?"
But that was just what nobody could tell her. Hawise leaped the chasm
deftly by declaring it an improper question. Eva said, "_Si bete_!" and
declined to say more.
"Well, I may be a fool," said Beatrice bluntly: "but I do not think you
are much better if you cannot tell me."
"Of course I could tell thee, if I chose!" answered Eva, with lofty
scorn.
"Then why dost thou not?" was the unanswerable reply.
Eva did not deign to respond. But when Bruno next appeared, Beatrice
put her question.
"The Church is what Christ builds on Himself: a schism is bred in man's
brain, contrary to holy Scripture."
In saying which, Bruno only quoted Bishop Grosteste.
"But, seeing men are fallible, how then can any human system claim to be
at all times The Church?" asked Beatrice.
"The true Church is not a human system at all," said he.
"Father, Beatrice actually fancies that the Archbishop of Antioch could
excommunicate the holy Father!" observed Hawise in tones of horror.
"I suppose any authority can excommunicate those below him, in the
Church visible," said Bruno, calmly: "in the invisible Jerusalem above,
which is the mother of us all, none excommunicates but God. `Every
branch in Me, not fruit-bearing, He taketh it away.' My daughters, it
would do us more good to bear that in mind, than to blame either the
Pope or the Archbishop."
And he walked away, as was his wont when he had delivered his sentence.
That afternoon, the Countess sent for Beatrice and Doucebelle to her own
bower. They found her seated by the window, with unusually idle hands,
and an expression of sore disturbance on her fair, serene face.
"There is bad news come, my damsels," she said, when the girls had made
their courtesies. "And I do not know how to tell my Magot. Perhaps one
of you might manage it better than I could. And she had better be told,
for she is sure to hear it in some way, and I would fain spare the child
all I can."
"About Sir Richard the Earl, Lady?" asked Beatrice.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account