61. In the passage of the _Metaphysics_ just referred to, Aristotle
speaks of Xenophanes as “the first partisan of the One,”[306] and the
context shows that he means to suggest he was the first of the Eleatics.
We have seen already that the certain facts of his life make it very
unlikely that he settled at Elea and founded a school there, and it is
probable that, as usual in such cases, Aristotle is simply reproducing
certain statements of Plato. At any rate, Plato had spoken of the
Eleatics as the “partisans of the Whole,”[307] and he had also spoken of
the school as “starting with Xenophanes and even earlier.”[308] The last
words, however, show clearly enough what he meant. Just as he called the
Herakleiteans “followers of Homer and still more ancient teachers,”[309]
so he attached the Eleatic school to Xenophanes and still earlier
authorities. We have seen in other instances how these playful and
ironical remarks of Plato were taken seriously by his successors, and we
need not let this fresh instance of the same thing influence our general
view of Xenophanes unduly.
Footnote 306:
_Met._ Α, 5. 986 b 21 (R. P. 101), πρῶτος τούτων ἑνίσας. The verb
ἑνίζειν occurs nowhere else, but is plainly formed on the analogy of
μηδίζειν, φιλιππίζειν, and the like. It is not likely that it means
“to unify.” Aristotle could easily have said ἑνώσας if he had meant
that.
Footnote 307:
_Tht._ 181 a 6, τοῦ ὅλου στασιῶται. The noun στασιῶτης has no other
meaning than “partisan.” There is no verb στασιοῦν “to make
stationary,” and such a formation would be against all analogy. The
derivation στασιώτας ... ἀπὸ τῆς στάσεως appears first in Sext.
_Math._ x. 46, from which passage we may infer that Aristotle used the
word, not that he gave the derivation.
Footnote 308:
_Soph._ 242 d 5 (R. P. 101 b). If the passage implies that Xenophanes
settled at Elea, it equally implies this of his predecessors. But Elea
was not founded till Xenophanes was in the prime of life.
Footnote 309:
_Tht._ 179 e 3, τῶν Ἡρακλειτείων ἤ, ὥσπερ σὺ λέγεις Ὁμηρείων καὶ ἔτι
παλαιοτέρων. In this passage, Homer stands to the Herakleiteans in
exactly the same relation as Xenophanes does to the Eleatics in the
_Sophist._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account