It has been pointed out that, in default of Hippolytos, our best account
of the Theophrastean doxography of Herakleitos is the fuller of the two
accounts given in Laertios Diogenes. It is as follows:—
His opinions on particular points are these:—
He held that Fire was the element, and that all things were an
exchange for fire, produced by condensation and rarefaction. But he
explains nothing clearly. All things were produced in opposition, and
all things were in flux like a river.
The all is finite and the world is one. It arises from fire, and is
consumed again by fire alternately through all eternity in certain
cycles. This happens according to fate. That which leads to the
becoming of the opposites is called War and Strife; that which leads
to the final conflagration is Concord and Peace.
He called change the upward and the downward path, and held that the
world comes into being in virtue of this. When fire is condensed it
becomes moist, and when compressed it turns to water; water being
congealed turns to earth, and this he calls the downward path. And,
again, the earth is in turn liquefied, and from it water arises, and
from that everything else; for he refers almost everything to the
evaporation from the sea. This is the path upwards. R. P. 36.
He held, too, that exhalations arose both from the sea and the land;
some bright and pure, others dark. Fire was nourished by the bright
ones, and moisture by the others.
He does not make it clear what is the nature of that which surrounds
the world. He held, however, that there were bowls in it with the
concave sides turned towards us, in which the bright exhalations were
collected and produced flames. These were the heavenly bodies.
The flame of the sun was the brightest and warmest; for the other
heavenly bodies were more distant from the earth; and for that reason
gave less light and heat. The moon, on the other hand, was nearer the
earth; but it moved through an impure region. The sun moved in a
bright and unmixed region, and at the same time was at just the right
distance from us. That is why it gives more heat and light. The
eclipses of the sun and moon were due to the turning of the bowls
upwards, while the monthly phases of the moon were produced by a
gradual turning of its bowl.
Day and night, months and seasons and years, rains and winds, and
things like these, were due to the different exhalations. The bright
exhalation, when ignited in the circle of the sun, produced day, and
the preponderance of the opposite exhalations produced night. The
increase of warmth proceeding from the bright exhalation produced
summer, and the preponderance of moisture from the dark exhalation
produced winter. He assigns the causes of other things in conformity
with this.
As to the earth, he makes no clear statement about its nature, any
more than he does about that of the bowls.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account