Empedokles also called the “four roots” by the names of certain
divinities—“shining Zeus, life-bringing Hera, Aidoneus, and Nestis” (fr.
6)—though there is some doubt as to how these names are to be
apportioned among the elements. Nestis is said to have been a Sicilian
water-goddess, and the description of her shows that she stands for
Water; but there is a conflict of opinion as to the other three. This,
however, need not detain us.[583] We are already prepared to find that
Empedokles called the elements gods; for all the early thinkers had
spoken in this way of whatever they regarded as the primary substance.
We must only remember that the word is not used in its religious sense.
Empedokles did not pray or sacrifice to the elements, and the use of
divine names is in the main an accident of the poetical form in which he
cast his system.
Footnote 583:
In antiquity the Homeric Allegorists made Hera Earth and Aidoneus Air,
a view which has found its way into Aetios from Poseidonios. It arose
as follows. The Homeric Allegorists were not interested in the science
of Empedokles, and did not see that his αἰθήρ was quite a different
thing from Homer’s ἀήρ. Now this is the dark element, and night is a
form of it, so it would naturally be identified with Aidoneus. Again,
Empedokles calls Hera φερέσβιος, and that is an old epithet of Earth
in Homer. Another view current in antiquity identified Hera with Air,
which is the theory of Plato’s _Cratylus_, and Aidoneus with Earth.
The Homeric Allegorists further identified Zeus with Fire, a view to
which they were doubtless led by the use of the word αἰθήρ. Now αἰθήρ
certainly means Fire in Anaxagoras, as we shall see, but there is no
doubt that in Empedokles it meant Air. It seems likely, then, that
Knatz is right (“Empedoclea” in _Schedae Philologicae Hermanno Usenero
oblatae_, 1891, pp. 1 sqq.) in holding that the bright Air of
Empedokles was Zeus. This leaves Aidoneus to stand for Fire; and
nothing could have been more natural for a Sicilian poet, with the
volcanoes and hot springs of his native island in mind, than this
identification. He refers to the fires that burn beneath the Earth
himself (fr. 52). If that is so, we shall have to agree with the
Homeric Allegorists that Hera is Earth; and there is certainly no
improbability in that.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account