_Ibid._ p. 137.
This theory marks in some respects an advance upon that of Empedokles.
It was a happy thought of Anaxagoras to make sensation depend upon
irritation by opposites, and to connect it with pain. Many modern
theories are based upon a similar idea.
That Anaxagoras regarded the senses as incapable of reaching the truth
of things is shown by the fragments preserved by Sextus. But we must
not, for all that, turn him into a sceptic. The saying preserved by
Aristotle[731] that “things are as we suppose them to be,” has no value
at all as evidence. It comes from some collection of apophthegms, not
from the treatise of Anaxagoras himself; and it had, as likely as not, a
moral application. He did say (fr. 21) that “the weakness of our senses
prevents our discerning the truth,” but this meant simply that we do not
see the “portions” of everything which are in everything; for instance,
the portions of black which are in the white. Our senses simply show us
the portions that prevail. He also said that the things which are seen
give us the power of seeing the invisible, which is the very opposite of
scepticism (fr. 21_a_).
Footnote 731:
_Met._ Δ, 5. 1009 b 25 (R. P. 161 a).
CHAPTER VII
THE PYTHAGOREANS
[Sidenote: The Pythagorean school.]
138. We have seen (§ 40) how the Pythagoreans, after losing their
supremacy at Kroton, concentrated themselves at Rhegion; but the school
founded there was soon broken up. Archippos stayed behind in Italy; but
Philolaos and Lysis, the latter of whom had escaped as a young man from
the massacre of Kroton, betook themselves to continental Hellas,
settling finally at Thebes. We know from Plato that Philolaos was there
some time during the latter part of the fifth century, and Lysis was
afterwards the teacher of Epameinondas.[732] Some of the Pythagoreans,
however, were able to return to Italy later on. Philolaos certainly did
so, and Plato implies that he had left Thebes some time before 399 B.C.,
the year in which Sokrates was put to death. In the fourth century, the
chief seat of the school is at Taras, and we find the Pythagoreans
heading the opposition to Dionysios of Syracuse. It is to this period
that Archytas belongs. He was the friend of Plato, and almost realised,
if he did not suggest, the ideal of the philosopher king. He ruled Taras
for years, and Aristoxenos tells us that he was never defeated in the
field of battle.[733] He was also the inventor of mathematical
mechanics. At the same time, Pythagoreanism had taken root in Hellas.
Lysis, we have seen, remained at Thebes, where Simmias and Kebes had
heard Philolaos, and there was an important community of Pythagoreans at
Phleious. Aristoxenos was personally acquainted with the last generation
of the school, and mentioned by name Xenophilos the Chalkidian from
Thrace, with Phanton, Echekrates, Diokles, and Polymnestos of Phleious.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account