Meyer, _Gesch. des Alterth._ ii. § 502, Anm. It is still necessary to
insist upon this, as the idea that the Pythagoreans represented the
“Dorian ideal” dies very hard. In his _Kulturhistorische Beiträge_
(Heft i. p. 59), Max C. P. Schmidt imagines that later writers call
the founder of the sect Pythagoras instead of Pythagores, as he is
called by Herakleitos and Demokritos, because he had become “a Dorian
of the Dorians.” The fact is simply that Πυθαγόρας is the Attic form
of Πυθαγόρης, and that the writers in question wrote Attic. Similarly,
Plato calls Archytas, who did belong to a Dorian state, Archytes,
though Aristoxenos and others retained the Dorian form of his name.
Footnote 204:
Kylon, the chief opponent of the Pythagoreans, is described by
Aristoxenos (Iambl. _V. Pyth._ 248) as γένει καὶ δόξῃ καὶ πλούτῳ
πρωτεύων τῶν πολιτῶν. Taras, later the chief seat of the Pythagoreans,
was a democracy. The truth is that, at this time, the new religion
appealed to the people rather than the aristocracies, which were apt
to be “free-thinking” (Meyer, _Gesch. des Alt._ iii. § 252).
Xenophanes, not Pythagoras, is their man.
Footnote 205:
We have the authority of Aristotle, fr. 186, 1510 b 20, for the
identification of Pythagoras with Apollo Hyperboreios. The names of
Abaris and Aristeas stand for a mystical movement parallel to the
Orphic, but based on the worship of Apollo. The later tradition makes
them predecessors of Pythagoras; and that this has some historical
basis, appears from Herod. iv. 13 sqq., and above all from the
statement that Aristeas had a statue at Metapontion, where Pythagoras
died. The connexion of Pythagoras with Zamolxis belongs to the same
order of ideas. As the legend of the Hyperboreans is Delian, we see
that the religion taught by Pythagoras was genuinely Ionian in its
origin.
[Sidenote: Downfall of the Order.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account