It will be some years before the debate of diffusion versus independent
invention comes anywhere near settlement. Much of Gladwin’s evidence for
diffusion is striking and not to be laughed aside—particularly the group
of Australian traits in our Southwest, and the Polynesian and Melanesian
traits in the area around the Gulf of Darien. His injection of Old World
voyagers between the northern and southern areas of the New World
explains certain puzzling matters; but the theory presents puzzles of
its own. Many culture traits of Middle America and Peru are not found in
Oceania: the use of cement in masonry and the vigesimal system of
numeration in Middle America; the amazingly intricate Maya calendar and
hieroglyphics with the first invention of zero; baked brick in two
Mexican sites; bronze in Peru; the hammock; the whistling jar; the
manioc press. Some of these New World traits must have been invented
here, but we are asked to believe that the others were forgotten in
Oceania and remembered in the Americas. One argument for trans-Pacific
diffusion is clear and cogent, however. It is hard to believe that the
men who voyaged as far as the Marquesas and Easter Island stopped there,
and so missed our long coast line. Certainly the sweet potato made the
ocean crossing in the reverse direction, but was it before Columbus?[18]
Other things went with the sweet potato, according to the great chemist
Gilbert N. Lewis. Without believing that man originated in South
America, he thinks that man first reached the neolithic level in the
area east of the Peruvian Andes while his fellow man in the rest of the
world was wandering in paleolithic darkness. In the Andean highlands,
man developed architecture, numeration, metallurgy, weaving, sculpture,
and so forth. He spread these things to Middle America 6,000 or 8,000
years ago, and then carried them across the Pacific to the Old
World.[19] As a whole, Lewis’s theory may be unacceptable; but his
arguments for diffusion and against independent invention are
persuasive.
In 1947 six Scandinavians demonstrated the possibility of an east-west
crossing by sailing and drifting 4,300 miles in 101 days on a primitive
raft of balsa logs from Peru to an atoll not many days from Tahiti.[20]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account