Speaking of Japanese buildings, Mr. R. H. Brunton, who has devoted
especial attention to them says that,[24] ‘to imagine that slight
buildings, such as are seen here (i.e. in Japan), are the best
calculated to withstand an earthquake shock is an error of the most
palpable kind.’ After describing the construction of a Japanese house
in pretty much the same terms as we have used, he says ‘that with its
unnecessarily heavy roof and weak framework it is a structure of all
others the worst adapted to withstand a heavy shock.’ He tells us,
further, that these views are sustained by the truest principles of
mechanics. In order to render buildings to some extent proof against
earthquakes, some of the heavy roofs in Tokio have been so constructed
that they are capable of sliding on the walls. Mr. Brunton mentions
a design for a house, the upper part of which is to rest on balls,
which roll on inverted cups fixed on the lower part of the building,
which is to be firmly embedded in the earth. A similar design was,
at the suggestion of Mallet, used to support the tables carrying the
apparatus of some of the lighthouses erected in Japan by Mr. Brunton.
The very existence of these designs seems to indicate that the ordinary
European house, however solidly and strongly it may be built, is not
sufficient to meet the conditions imposed upon it. What is required,
is something that will give way—an approximation to the timber frame
of a Japanese house, so strongly condemned by Mr. Brunton and others.
The crucial test of the value of the Japanese structure, as compared
with the modern buildings of brick and stone, is undoubtedly to be
found by an appeal to the buildings themselves. So far as my own
experience has gone, I must say that I have never seen any signs in
the Japanese timber buildings which could be attributed to the effects
of earthquakes, and His Excellency Yamao Yozo, Vice Minister of Public
Works, who has made the study of the buildings of Japan a speciality,
told me that none of the temples and palaces, although many of them
are several centuries old, and although they have been shaken by small
earthquakes and also by many severe ones, show any signs of having
suffered. The greatest damage wrought by large earthquakes appears to
have resulted from the influx of large waves or from fires. In every
case where an earthquake has been accompanied by great destruction,
by consulting the books describing the same, it can be seen, from the
illustrations in these books portraying conflagrations, that this
destruction was chiefly due to fire. When we remember that nearly
all Japanese houses are constructed of materials that are readily
inflammable, it is not hard to imagine how destruction of this kind
has come about. To a Japanese, living as he does in a house which has
been compared to a tinder-box, fire is one of his greatest enemies,
and in a city like Tokio it is not at all uncommon to see during the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive