[57] _Vide_ Provost Creech, quoted in Chambers’s _Traditions of Edinburgh_. [58] Murray of Broughton, Prince Charlie’s secretary, who afterwards gave evidence against the Cause. [59] Presently Jeffrey, in his slashing review of _Marmion_ in the _Edinburgh Review_, was to accuse Scott of want of patriotism. He dined with Scott that night at Castle Street, and found Scott as hospitable and kind as ever; but from that moment Scott broke off his connection with the _Review_. [60] Lockhart’s _Life of Scott_. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black, 1884. [61] Dalkeith Palace, the residence of the Dukes of Buccleuch, is held by them, as Craigmillar used to be held, on the understanding that the Sovereign may command it as a Royal residence. [62] “I return no more.” [63] The architect was Kemp, who, when a poor lad, trudging along the Selkirk road with his joiner’s tools on his back, had been given “a lift” by the kindly Sir Walter Scott as he drove by. Shortly after the erection of the monument Kemp was drowned. [64] Truro Cathedral, and the great Roman Catholic Cathedral at Westminster, both built since, are larger. [65] This is often erroneously called “Old Parliament Hall,” a name that not only limits the uses to which it was habitually put, and thus lessens its interest, but also gives the wrong impression that the Scottish Parliaments were held there, and there only. The Scottish Parliaments were held wherever the King happened to be. If the King was in Edinburgh, they were held in Edinburgh, either at this hall in the Castle, or at the Tolbooth. [66] Miss Warrender’s _Walks near Edinburgh_, p. 33 (footnote). End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Edinburgh, by Rosaline Masson