But for the phrase “Hume’s Lectures once done with, I flung the thing away for ever,” quoted by Mr. Froude as from “a note somewhere,” I should, on the evidence of handwriting, etc., have decided unhesitatingly for the second and more extensive of the two hypotheses.—The attendance on the Chemistry Class, which would become a fact if that hypothesis were correct, would be of some independent interest. With Carlyle’s turn for science at that time, it was not unlikely. I may add that, from talks with him, I have an impression that, some time or other, he must have attended Professor Jameson’s class of Natural History. He had certainly heard Jameson lecture pretty frequently; for he described Jameson’s lecturing humorously and to the life, the favourite topic of his recollection being Jameson’s discourse on the order _Glires_ in the Linnæan Zoology. Though I have looked over the Matriculation Lists and also the preserved class-lists pretty carefully from 1809 to 1824, it is just possible that Carlyle’s name in one of Jameson’s class-lists within that range of time may have escaped me. The only other Professor, not already mentioned in the text, that I remember to have heard him talk of was Dr. Andrew Brown, Professor of Rhetoric and Belles Lettres; but _him_ he knew, I think, only by occasional dropping in at his lectures. Footnote 22: Carlyle to a correspondent, in one of Mr. Ireland’s copies of letters: _Conway_, p. 178. Footnote 23: Ditto, _ibid._ p. 180. Footnote 24: Ditto, _ibid._ pp. 201, 202. Footnote 25: Carlyle to his brother John, quoted in Mr. Froude’s Article. Footnote 26: _Reminiscences_, ii. 16, 11. Footnote 27: Quoted at p. 57 of Mr. William Howie Wylie’s excellent volume entitled _Carlyle: The Man and His Books_. Footnote 28: Mr. Ireland’s copies of Letters, in _Conway_, p. 171. Footnote 29: _Ibid._ p. 180. Footnote 30: Quoted in Mr. Froude’s Article. Footnote 31: Quoted _ibid._ Footnote 32: