Egypt of the Pharaohs and of the KhedivéZincke, F. Barham (Foster Barham)
History
Egypt of the Pharaohs and of the Khedivé
Zincke, F. Barham (Foster Barham)
Egypt -- Description and travel; Egypt -- History
But there appears to some a preliminary question: that of the
right of interpretation. About this there, however, can be no real
question at all, even among those who support what we call the popular
interpretation. How can they deny to others the right they claim for
themselves, of adopting the interpretation that appears to them most in
accordance with truth and fact? The third, the twelfth, the sixteenth,
and all other centuries, had a right to interpret the document in the way
which at the time seemed true. The nineteenth century has the same right.
The men of other times interpreted it according to the combination of
knowledge, and of ignorance, that was in them. We must do the same.
Let us see, then, what is the difference between the popular, and the
historical methods of interpretation. Proximately we shall find it very
great; ultimately not much. But the point before us will not be fully
understood until it be seen in a distinct concrete instance. The popular
method goes on the assumption that the modes of thought, and the modes
of expression of early ages, and of other races of men, must be accepted
by us in the sense in which we must take anything addressed to ourselves
by a contemporary author. This, the historical method tells us, is an
impossibility. It has been rendered impossible by subsequent advances
in knowledge, in the generalization of ideas, and in language through a
larger use of general and abstract terms. The historical method says that
archaic modes of thought, and modes of expression, must be translated
into our modes of thought, and our modes of expression.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account