It is the fertility of the Einsteinian system which proves that it
is strong and sound. Are the new beings with which it has peopled
science—the discoveries predicted by it—legitimate children? The
Newtonians say that they are not. But in properly ordered science, as
in an ideal State, it is the children that matter, not their legitimacy.
At all events the vigorous counter-offensive of M. Painlevé has driven
back to their lines the over-zealous apostles of the new gospel, who
thought that they had pulverised classic science beyond hope of
recovery. Each side now remains in its positions. There is no longer
any question of regarding the Newtonian conception of the world as a
piece of childlike barbarism. A different conception is now opposed
to it—that is all. The war between them is as yet undecided, and
may remain for ever undecided, as the weapons with which it might be
possible to bring it to an issue are sealed up for ever in the arsenal
of metaphysics.
* * * * *
Whatever may happen, Einstein’s teaching has a power of synthesis and
prediction which will inevitably incorporate its majestic system of
equations in the science of the future.
M. Émile Picard, perpetual secretary of the Academy of Sciences, and
one of the luminous and profound thinkers of our time, has asked if
it is an advance “to try, as Einstein has done, to reduce physics
to geometry.” Without lingering over this question, which may be
insoluble, like all speculative questions, we will conclude with the
distinguished mathematician that the only things which matter are the
agreement of the final formulæ with the facts and the analytic mould in
which the theory casts the phenomena.
Considered from this angle, Einstein’s theory has the solidity of
bronze. Its correctness consists in its explanatory force and in the
experimental discoveries predicted by it and at once verified.
What changes in theories are the pictures we form of the objects
between which science discovers and establishes relations. Sometimes we
alter these pictures, but the relations remain true, if they are based
upon observed facts. Thanks to this common fund of truth, even the most
ephemeral theories do not wholly die. They pass on to each other, like
the ancient runners with their torch, the one accessible reality: the
laws that express the relations of things.
To-day it happens that two theories together clasp the sacred torch.
The Einsteinian and the Newtonian vision of the world are two faithful
reflections of it: just as the two images, polarised in opposite
directions, which Iceland spar shows us in its strange crystal both
share the light of the same object.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account