1. Moving objects are contracted in the stationary
ether, the fixed substratum of all phenomena. This
contraction is real, and it increases with the velocity
of the body relatively to the ether. That is Lorentz’s
explanation.
2. Moving objects are contracted relatively to any
observer whatsoever. This contraction is only apparent,
and is due to the laws of the propagation of
light. It increases with the velocity of the moving
body relatively to the observer. That is Einstein’s
explanation.
* * * * *
But there is at least one other possible explanation. It introduces
new and strange hypotheses, but they are by no means absurd. Indeed,
it is especially in physics that truth may at times seem improbable.
This explanation will show how we may account for the result of the
Michelson experiment apart from either Lorentz or Einstein.
This third explanatory hypothesis is as follows. Every material body
bears along with it, as a sort of atmosphere, the ether that is
bound up with it. There is, in addition, a stationary ether in the
interstellar spaces; an ether insensible to the motion of the material
bodies that move in it, and which we may, to distinguish it from the
ether bound up with bodies, call the “super-ether.” This super-ether
occupies the whole of interstellar space, and near the heavenly bodies
it is superimposed upon the ether which they bear along. The ether
and the super-ether interpenetrate each other just as they penetrate
matter, and the vibrations they transmit spread independently. When a
material body sends out series of waves in the ether which surrounds
it, these move relatively to it with the constant velocity of light.
But when they have traversed the relatively thin stratum of ether bound
up with the material body, which merges gradually in the super-ether,
they spread in the latter, and it is relatively to this that they
progressively take their velocity.
It is like a boat crossing the Lake of Geneva at a certain speed. About
the middle of the lake it has this speed relatively to the narrow
current which the River Rhone makes there, and then it resumes it
relatively to the stationary lake.
In the same way the luminous rays of the stars, although they come
from bodies which are approaching or receding from us, have the same
velocity when they reach us, and this will be the common velocity which
the super-ether imposes upon them. Thus also, on the other hand, the
stellar rays that reach our telescopes will be transmitted to us by the
super-ether, without the very thin stratum of mobile ether bound up
with the earth being able to disturb their propagation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account