Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Philosophy
Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000
Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Relativity (Physics)
Suppose we have a set of "elements" of some sort--any sort. Suppose
that these elements possess one or more fundamental identifying
characteristics, analogous to the coordinates of a point, and
which, like these coordinates, are capable of being given numerical
values. Suppose we find that no two elements of the set possess
identically the same set of defining values. Suppose finally--and
this is the critical test--that the elements of the set are such that,
no matter what numerical values we may specify, it we do specify the
proper number of defining magnitudes we define by these an actual
element of the set, that corresponds to this particular collection
of values. Our elements then share with the real number system
the property of leaving no holes, of constituting a continuous
succession in every dimension which they possess. We have then a
continuum. Whatever its elements, whatever the character of their
numerical identifiers, whatever the number n of these which stands for
its dimension, there may be no holes or we have no continuum. There
must be an element for every possible combination of n numbers
we can name, and no two of these combinations may give the same
element. Granted this condition, our elements constitute a continuum.
As I have remarked, it is not easy to cite examples of continua which
shall mean anything to the person unaccustomed to the term. The
totality of carbon-oxygen-nitrogen-hydrogen compounds suggested
by one essayist as an example is not a continuum at all, for the
set contains elements corresponding only to integer values of the
numbers which tell us how many atoms of each substance occur in the
molecule. We cannot have a compound containing $\sqrt2$ carbon atoms,
or $3\pi$ oxygen atoms. Perhaps the most satisfactory of the continua,
outside the three Euclidean space-continua already cited, [is the
manifold of music notes. This is four-dimensional; each note has
four distinctions--length, pitch, intensity, timbre--to distinguish
it perfectly, to tell how long, how high, how loud, how rich.]263
We might have a little difficulty in reducing the characteristic of
richness to numerical expression, but presumably it could be done;
and we should then be satisfied that every possible combination of four
values, $l$, $p$, $i$, $t$ for these four identifying characteristics
would give us a musical effect, and one to be confused with no other.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account