Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
For (_a_) reality cannot consist of _mere_ relations. Every relation
implies two or more terms which are related. And these terms cannot be
created by the relation itself. In every relation the terms have _some_
character of their own over and beyond the mere property of being terms
in that relation. Thus, to take a simple example, the successive terms
of the series of ordinal numbers express in themselves nothing beyond
determinate position in an ordered series, but when they are applied to
the actual arrangement of any content in serial order, that content is
(_c_) not created by the arrangement of it in an ordered series of
terms, and (_b_) is dependent for the actual order of its terms upon
some positive character of its own. In other words, whenever you
actually count you count something other than the names of the numbers
you employ, and you count it in an order which depends on the character
of the particular things counted.[88] And so generally of all relations.
A question has been raised which presents considerable difficulty and
cannot be discussed here, whether there are or are not merely _external_
relations (_i.e._ relations which are independent of the special
qualities of their terms). But even if we admit that there may be such
merely external relations, which do not depend upon the nature of the
terms between which they subsist, it is at least clear that there cannot
be relations without _any_ terms, and that the terms are not created out
of nothing by the relation between them.[89] Perhaps it might be
rejoined that what I call the terms of a certain relation, though no
doubt not created by that particular relation, may be themselves
analysed into other relations, and those again into others _ad
indefinitum_. Thus it might be said that the term A of the relation A-B
may no doubt have a quality of its own which is not created by this
relation. But this quality, call it A_{1}, is found on analysis to be
resoluble into the relation C-D, and the quality C_{1} of C again into
the relation E-F, and so on without end. This would not, however, amount
to a reduction of qualities to mere relations. For it would give us, as
the unit of our scheme of things, a pair of terms or qualities in
relation; and however often we repeated the process of analysis, we
should still always be left with the same type of triad, two terms and a
relation, as the result of analysis. Whatever its worth, this particular
solution falls under our second alternative, and must be considered in
connection with it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account