Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
Change is not, however, the only instance of the principle of Ground and
Consequence. These two aspects may also be found in systematic wholes
which contain no element of succession in time, _e.g._ in a body of
logical deductions from a few fundamental premisses. The special
peculiarity of the case of Change is that it is the principle of Ground
and Consequence as applied to a material which is successive _in time_.
As thus applied, the principle has received the special name of the
_Principle of Sufficient Reason_, and may be formulated thus: _Nothing
takes place unless there is a sufficient reason why it should occur
rather than not_. It is clear that such a proposition is a mere result
of the application of the conception of Reality as a systematic whole to
the special case of the existence of the successive in time. It is
therefore simply one case of the fundamental axiom of all knowledge, the
axiom that what truly exists is a coherent whole.[103] We must of course
observe that the principle does nothing to solve the perhaps insoluble
problem _why_ succession in time should be a feature of experience. This
is a question which could only be answered if we could show that
succession in time is a logical consequence of the existence of any
multiplicity forming a systematic whole. Until we are able to establish
this result, we have simply to accept succession as a datum of our
experience. (Yet for some light upon the problem, see _infra_, Bk. III
chap. 4, § 9)
§ 4. _Causality._ So far we have said nothing of a concept which is much
more familiar in the popular treatment of the problem of Change than
that of Ground and Consequence, the concept of _Cause_. In proceeding to
discuss this concept, it is necessary in the first place to explain
which of the numerous senses of the word we are taking for examination.
There was an old scholastic distinction, which still reappears
occasionally in philosophical writings, between the _Causa cognoscendi_,
or reason for affirming a truth, and the _Causa existendi_ or _fiendi_,
the cause of the occurrence of an event. It is this latter meaning of
the word “cause,” the meaning which is predominant wherever the term is
used in modern scientific language, that we shall have in view in the
following sections.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account