Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
A word may be said about the attempts which philosophers have made to
extricate themselves from the difficulty without giving up Causality as
an ultimate principle of explanation. The least philosophical method of
escape is that of arbitrarily postulating a first cause with no
preceding cause, which amounts to the same thing as a beginning of
existence or a first moment of time. This way out of the difficulty
obviously amounts to an arbitrary desertion of the causal principle at
the point where it becomes inconvenient to remain faithful to it.
Whatever the nature of the event you pitch upon as your “first cause,”
the causal principle, if logically valid at all, is just as applicable
here as anywhere else Your “first cause” must have had a previous cause,
or else the whole causal scheme must be, as we have contended that it
is, the illogical and imperfect perversion of a genuine principle of
systematic connection, useful and indeed indispensable in practice, but
quite indefensible in theory.
It would not help you out of the difficulty to distinguish between a
first event and a first moment of time, by postulating a first cause
with an indefinite lapse of empty time before it. For the causal
principle would then require you to look for the determining conditions
of the first event in the preceding lapse of empty time. But this lapse,
because merely empty, cannot contain the determining conditions for any
special occurrence in preference to others. This is why the conception
of a beginning of the causal series in time, with an empty lapse before
it, has always led to the insoluble riddle, “Why did God create the
world when He did, rather than at some other point of time?”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account