_The Relation of Polyp and Medusa._--Many views have been put forward as
to the morphological relationship between the two types of person in the
Hydromedusae. For the most part, polyp and medusa have been regarded as
modifications of a common type, a view supported by the existence, among
Scyphomedusae (q.v.), of sessile polyp-like medusae (_Lucernaria_, &c.).
R. Leuckart in 1848 compared medusae in general terms to flattened
polyps. G. J. Allman [1] put forward a more detailed view, which was as
follows. In some polyps the tentacles are webbed at the base, and it was
supposed that a medusa was a polyp of this kind set free, the umbrella
being a greatly developed web or membrane extending between the
tentacles. A very different theory was enunciated by E. Metchnikoff. In
some hydroids the founder-polyp, developed from a planula after
fixation, throws out numerous outgrowths from the base to form the
hydrorhiza; these outgrowths may be radially arranged so as to form by
contact or coalescence a flat plate. Mechnikov considered the plate thus
formed at the base of the polyp as equivalent to the umbrella, and the
body of the polyp as equivalent to the manubrium, of the medusa; on this
view the marginal tentacles almost invariably present in medusae are new
formations, and the tentacles of the polyp are represented in the medusa
by the oral arms which may occur round the mouth, and which sometimes,
e.g. in _Margelidae_, have the appearance and structure of tentacles.
Apart from the weighty arguments which the development furnishes against
the theories of Allman and Mechnikov, it may be pointed out that neither
hypothesis gives a satisfactory explanation of a structure universally
present in medusae of whatever class, namely the endoderm-lamella,
discovered by the brothers O. and R. Hertwig. It would be necessary to
regard this structure as a secondary extension of the endoderm in the
tentacle-web, on Allman's theory, or between the outgrowths of the
hydrorhiza, on Mechnikov's hypothesis. The development, on the contrary,
shows unequivocally that the endoderm-lamella arises as a local
coalescence of the endodermal linings of a primitively extensive gastral
space.
The question is one intimately connected with the view taken as to the
nature and individuality of polyp, medusa and gonophore respectively. On
this point the following theories have been put forward.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account