The North American Indians have been the subject of numerous popular
fallacies, some of which have gained world-wide currency. Here belongs
a mass of pseudo-scientific and thoroughly unscientific literature
embodying absurd and extravagant theories and speculations as to the
origin of the aborigines and their "civilizations" which derive them
(in most extraordinary ways sometimes), in recent or in remote
antiquity, from all regions of the Old World--Egypt and Carthage,
Phoenicia and Canaan, Asia Minor and the Caucasus, Assyria and
Babylonia, Persia and India, Central Asia and Siberia, China and
Tibet, Korea, Japan, the East Indies, Polynesia, Greece and ancient
Celtic Europe and even medieval Ireland and Wales. Favourite theories
of this sort have made the North American aborigines the descendants
of refugees from sunken Atlantis, Tatar warriors, Malayo-Polynesian
sea-farers, Hittite immigrants from Syria, the "Lost Ten Tribes of
Israel," &c., or attributed their social, religious and political
ideas and institutions to the advent of stray junks from Japan,
Buddhist votaries from south-eastern Asia, missionaries from early
Christian Europe, Norse vikings, Basque fishermen and the like.
Particularly interesting are the theories of "Welsh (or white)
Indians" and the "Lost Ten Tribes." The myth of the "Welsh Indians,"
reputed to be the descendants of a colony founded about A.D. 1170 by
Prince Madoc (well known from Southey's poem), has been studied by
James Mooney (_Amer. Anthrop._ iv., 1891, 393-394), who traces its
development from statements in an article in _The Turkish Spy_,
published in London about 1730. At first these "Welsh Indians," who
are subsequently described as speaking Welsh, possessing Welsh Bibles,
beads, crucifixes, &c., are placed near the Atlantic coast and
identified with the Tuscaroras, an Iroquoian tribe, but by 1776 they
had retreated inland to the banks of the Missouri above St Louis. A
few years later they were far up the Red river, continuing, as time
went on, to recede farther and farther westward, being identified
successively with the Mandans, in whose language Catlin thought he
detected a Welsh element, the Moqui, a Pueblos tribe of north-eastern
Arizona, and the Modocs (here the name was believed to re-echo Madoc)
of south-western Oregon, until at last they vanished over the waters
of the Pacific Ocean. The theory that the American Indians were the
"Lost Ten Tribes of Israel" has not yet entirely disappeared from
ethnological literature. Many of the identities and resemblances in
ideas, customs and institutions between the American Indians and the
ancient Hebrews, half-knowledge or distorted views of which formed
the basis of the theory, are discussed, and their real significance
pointed out by Colonel Garrick Mallery in his valuable address on
"Israelite and Indian: A Parallel in Planes of Culture" (_Proc. Amer.
Assoc. Adv.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account