Experience has presented itself as the complex result of relation
between the ego or subject and the world of phenomena. Reason may
therefore attempt a completed explanation either of the ego or of the
world of phenomena or of the total relation between them. The three
inquiries correspond to the subjects of the three ancient metaphysical
sciences, rational psychology, rational cosmology, rational theology.
It is readily seen, in regard to the first of them, that all attempts
to determine the nature of the ego as a simple, perdurable, immaterial
substance rest upon a confusion between the ego as pure logical unity
and the ego as object of intuition, and involve a transcendent use of
the categories of experience. It profits not to apply such categories
to the soul, for no intuition corresponding to them is or can be
given. The idea of the soul must be regarded as transcendent. So too
when we endeavour, with the help of the categories of quantity,
quality, relation and modality, to determine the nature and relation
of parts of the world, we find that reason is landed in a peculiar
difficulty. Any solution that can be given is too narrow for the
demands of reason and too wide for the restrictions of understanding.
The transcendent employment of the categories leads to antinomy, or
equally balanced statements of apparently contradictory results. Due
attention to the relation between understanding and reason enables us
to solve the antinomies and to discover their precise origin and
significance. Finally, the endeavour to find in the conception of God,
as the supreme reality, the explanation of experience, is seen to lead
to no valid conclusion. There is not any intuition given whereby we
might show the reality of our idea of a Supreme Being. So far as
knowledge is concerned, God remains a transcendental ideal.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account