the evidence of molar changes due to the obvious parts of bodies,
science first comes to believe in molecular changes due to
imperceptible particles, and then tries to conceive the ideas of
particles, molecules, atoms, electrons. The conceptual logic supposes
that conception always precedes judgment; but the truth is that
sensory judgment begins and inferential judgment ends by preceding
conception. The supposed triple order--conception, judgment,
reasoning--is defective and false. The real order is sensation and
sensory judgment, conception, memory and memorial judgment, experience
and experiential judgment, inference, inferential judgment,
inferential conception. This is not all: inferential conceptions are
inadequate, and finally fail. They are often symbolical; that is, we
conceive one thing only by another like it, e.g. atoms by minute
bodies not nearly small enough. Often the symbol is not like. What
idea can the physicist form of intraspatial ether? What believer in
God pretends to conceive Him as He really is? We believe many things
that we cannot conceive; as Mill said, the inconceivable is not the
incredible; and the point of science is not what we can conceive but
what we should believe on evidence. Conception is the weakest,
judgment the strongest power of man's mind. Sense before conception is
the original cause of judgment; and inference from sense enables
judgment to continue after conception ceases. Finally, as there is
judgment without conception, so there is conception without judgment.
We often say "I understand, but do not decide." But this suspension of
judgment is a highly refined act, unfitted to the beginning of
thought. Conception begins as a condition of memory, and after a long
continuous process of inference ends in mere ideation. The conceptual
logic has made the mistake of making ideation a stage in thought prior
to judgment.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account