the result of an attempt to explain the origin of the "given" in
consciousness. The _form_ of things is admittedly subjective; the mind
endeavours to explain the _material_ of the given in the same terms, an
attempt which is not only impossible but involves a denial of the
elementary laws of thought. Knowledge of the given is, therefore,
essentially incomplete. Complete or perfect knowledge is confined to the
domain of pure thought, to logic and mathematics. Thus the problem of
the "thing-in-itself" is dismissed from the inquiry, and philosophy is
limited to the sphere of pure thought. The Kantian categories are,
indeed, demonstrable and true, but their application to the given is
meaningless and unthinkable. By this critical scepticism Maimon takes up
a position intermediate between Kant and Hume. Hume's attitude to the
empirical is entirely supported by Maimon. The casual concept, as given
by experience, expresses not a necessary objective order of things, but
an ordered scheme of perception; it is subjective and cannot be
postulated as a concrete law apart from consciousness. The main argument
of the _Transcendentalphilosophie_ not only drew from Kant, who saw it
in MS., the remark that Maimon alone of his all critics had mastered the
true meaning of his philosophy, but also directed the path of most
subsequent criticism.
Maimon's chief works, in addition to the above quoted, are _Philos.
Wörterbuch_ (1791); _Streifereien im Gebiete der Philos._(1793); _Über
die Progresse der Philos._ (1793); _Die Kategorien des Aristoteles mit
Anmerkungen erläutert_ (1794); _Versuch einer neuen Logik_ (1794 and
1798); _Kritische Untersuchungen über den menschl. Geist_ (1797). See
_S. Maimons Lebensgeschichte von ihm selbst beschrieben_ (1792, ed. K.
P. Moritz; Eng. trans. by J. C. Murray, 1888); Wolff, _Maimoniana_
(1813); Witte, _S. Maimon_ (1876).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account