Maine de Biran's first essays in philosophy were written avowedly from
the point of view of Locke and Condillac, but even in them he was
brought to signalize the essential fact on which his later speculation
turns. Dealing with the formation of habits, he is compelled to note
that passive impressions, however transformed, do not furnish a
complete or adequate explanation. With Laromiguière he distinguishes
attention as an active effort, of no less importance than the passive
receptivity of sense, and with Butler distinguishes passively formed
customs from active habits. He finally arrived at the conclusion that
Condillac's notion of passive receptivity as the one source of
conscious experience was not only an error in fact but an error of
method--in short, that the mechanical mode of viewing consciousness as
formed by external influence was fallacious and deceptive. For it he
proposed to substitute the genetic method, whereby human conscious
experience might be exhibited as growing or developing from its
essential basis in connexion with external conditions. The essential
basis he finds in the real consciousness, of self as an active
striving power, and the stages of its development, corresponding to
what one may call the relative importance of the external conditions
and the reflective clearness of self-consciousness he designates as
the affective, the perceptive and the reflective. In connexion with
this Biran treats most of the obscure problems which arise in dealing
with conscious experience, such as the mode by which the organism is
cognized, the mode by which the organism is distinguished from
extra-organic things, and the nature of those general ideas by which
the relations of things are known to us--cause, power, force, &c.
In the latest stage of his speculation Biran distinguishes the animal
existence from the human, under which the three forms above noted are
classed, and both from the life of the spirit, in which human thought
is brought into relation with the supersensible, divine system of
things. This stage is left imperfect. Altogether Biran's work presents
a very remarkable specimen of deep metaphysical thinking directed by
preference to the psychological aspect of experience.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account