Besides the contemporary documents enumerated above (Koranic texts,
rescripts and authentic traditions) many of the events were celebrated
by poets, whose verses were ostensibly incorporated in the standard
biography of Ibn Ishaq; in the abridgment of that biography which we
possess many of these are obelized as spurious, and, indeed, what we
know of the procedure of those who professed to collect early poetry
gives us little confidence in the genuineness of such odes. A few,
however, seem to stand criticism, and the _diwan_ (or collection of
poems) attributed to Hassan b. Thabit is ordinarily regarded as his.
Though they rarely give detailed descriptions of events, their
attestation is at times of value, e.g. for the story that the bodies
of the slain at Badr were cast by the Prophet into a pit. Besides
this, the narratives of eyewitnesses of important events, or of those
who had actually taken part in them, were eagerly sought by the second
generation, and some of these were committed to writing well before
the end of the 1st century. The practice instituted by the second
Caliph, of assigning pensions proportioned to the length of time in
which the recipient had been a member of the Islamic community, led to
the compilation of certain rolls, and to the accurate preservation of
the main sequence of events from the commencement of the mission, and
for the detailed sequence after the Flight, which presently became an
era (beginning with the first month of the year in which the Flight
took place). The procedure whereby the original dates of the events
(so far as they were remembered) were translated into the Moslem
calendar--for something of this sort must have been done--is unknown,
and is unlikely to have been scientific.
Mahomet's conduct being made the standard of right and wrong, there
was little temptation to "whitewash" him, although the original
biography by Ibn Ishaq appears to have contained details which the
author of the abridgment omitted as scandalous. The preservation of so
much that was historical left little room for the introduction of
miraculous narrations; these therefore either belong to the obscure
period of his life or can be easily eliminated; thus the narratives of
the Meccan council at which the assassination of Mahomet was decided,
of the battles of Badr, Uhud and Honain, and the death of Sad`b. Mu
`adh, would lose nothing by the omission of the angels and the devil,
though a certain part is assigned the one or the other on all these
occasions. We should have expected biographies which were published
when the `Abbasids were reigning to have falsified history for the
purpose of glorifying `Abbas, their progenitor; the very small extent
to which this expectation is justified is a remarkable testimony to
their general trustworthiness.
RELATIVES OF THE PROHET[1]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account