England, Canada and the Great WarDesjardins, L. G. (Louis Georges)
History
England, Canada and the Great War
Desjardins, L. G. (Louis Georges)
Great Britain -- Colonies -- Canada; Imperialism; World War, 1914-1918; World War, 1914-1918 -- Canada
"The Holy See, in his Appeal of the first of August, did not
consider, out of deference for the leaders of the belligerent
peoples, that he should mention it, preferring to leave to
themselves the care of determining it, but for him, the only
practical system and, moreover, easy to apply with some good
will on both sides, would be the following: to suppress, with
one accord between civilized nations, military obligatory
service; to constitute an arbitration tribunal, as already said
in the Pontifical Appeal, to settle international questions;
finally, to prevent infractions, to establish universal
"boycottage" against any nation attempting to reestablish
military obligatory service, on refusing either to lay an
international question before the arbitration tribunal, or to
abide by its decision."
Cardinal Gasparri then points to the ante-war British and American
systems of military "voluntarism", in the following terms:--
"As a matter of fact, omitting other considerations, the recent
example of England and America testifies in favour of the
adoption of this system. England and America had, in effect,
voluntary service, and, to take an efficient part in the present
war, they were obliged to adopt conscription. It proves that
voluntary service well supplies the necessary contingent to
maintain public order (and is public order not maintained in
England and America just as well, if not better, than in the
other nations?) but it does not supply the enormous armies
required for modern warfare. Consequently in suppressing, with
one accord between civilized nations, obligatory service to
replace it by voluntary service, disarmament with all the happy
consequences above indicated would be automatically obtained
without any perturbation of public order."
"For the last century, conscription has been the true cause of
calamities which have afflicted society: to reach a simultaneous
and reciprocal suppression will be the true remedy. In fact,
once suppressed, conscription could be reestablished only by a
law; and for such a law, even with the present constitution of
the Central Empires, Parliamentary approbation would be required
(which approbation would be most improbable for many reasons and
above all on account of the sad experience of the present war);
in this way, what is so much desired, for the maintenance of
agreements, would be obtained: the peoples' guarantee. If, on the
other hand, the right to make peace or war was given to the
people by way of =referendum=, or at least to Parliament, peace
between nations would be assured, as much at least as it is
possible in this world."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account