Ballads, English -- England -- Texts; Ballads, Scots -- Scotland -- Texts
"There shall nae mantle cross my back,[L33]
Nor kame gae in my hair,
Neither shall coal nor candle light 35
Shine in my bower mair;
Nor shall I chuse anither love,
Until the day I die,
Since the lowlands of Holland
Hae twinn'd my love and me." 40
"O haud your tongue, my daughter dear,
Be still, and be content;
There are mair lads in Galloway,
Ye need nae sair lament."
"O there is nane in Galloway,[L45] 45
There's nane at a' for me;
For I never loved a lad but ane,
And he's drowned in the sea."
33-36, 45-48. With the conclusion of this piece may be compared a
passage from _Bonny Bee-Ho'm_, vol. iii. p. 57.
"Ohon, alas! what shall I do,
Tormented night and day!
I never loved a love but ane,
And now he's gone away.
"But I will do for my true love
What ladies would think sair;
For seven years shall come and gae,
Ere a kaime gae in my hair.
"There shall neither a shoe gae on my foot,
Nor a kaime gae in my hair,
Nor ever a coal or candle light
Shine in my bower nae mair."
See also _The Weary Coble o' Cargill_.
BOOK III.
THE TWA BROTHERS.
From Jamieson's _Popular Ballads_, i. 59.
The ballad of the _Twa Brothers_, like many of the domestic
tragedies with which it is grouped in this volume, is by no means
the peculiar property of the island of Great Britain. It finds an
exact counterpart in the Swedish ballad _Sven i Rosengård_, _Svenska
F. V._, No. 67, Arwidsson, No. 87, A, B, which, together with a
Finnish version of the same story, thought to be derived from the
Swedish, will be found translated in our Appendix. _Edward_, in
Percy's _Reliques_, has the same general theme, with the difference
that a father is murdered instead of a brother. Motherwell[C] has
printed a ballad (_Son Davie_) closely agreeing with _Edward_,
except that the crime is again fratricide. He has also furnished
another version of _The Twa Brothers_, in which the catastrophe is
the consequence of an accident, and this circumstance has led the
excellent editor to tax Jamieson with altering one of the most
essential features of the ballad, by filling out a defective stanza
with four lines that make one brother to have slain the other in a
quarrel. Jamieson is, however, justified in giving this more
melancholy character to the story, by the tenor of all the kindred
pieces, and by the language of his own. It will be observed that
both in _Edward_ and _Son Davie_, the wicked act was not only
deliberate, but was even instigated by the mother. The departure
from the original is undoubtedly on the part of Motherwell's copy,
which has softened down a shocking incident to accommodate a modern
and refined sentiment. But Jamieson is artistically, as well as
critically right, since the effect of the contrast of the remorse of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account