English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised EditionBond, Francis
History
English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised Edition
Bond, Francis
Cathedrals -- England; Cathedrals -- Wales
narrower aisles, the multiplied obstructive masses of the various piers,
hide the dome away from view. Rightly designed, a great central dome
ought to be all in all; everything should lead up to it; everything
should be suppressed that does not lend it strength or grace. Its thrusts
are great, and cannot be resisted by the piers of aisles, unless the
piers are positive mountains of masonry; aisles, then, should be omitted.
The dome should rest on four arches, and their thrusts should be resisted
by the solid walls of the unaisled nave and choir and the two transepts.
And these four great limbs of the church should be kept short, to give
the dome full value.
[Illustration: NAVE.]
Again, just as the central dome dictates the plan of the church, so it
should dictate the form of the vaulted roof. There were three types
of vault at Wren’s disposal. One was the intersecting vault, a second
the domical vault, a third the waggon or tunnel vault. The first is
altogether out of harmony with a central dome, though Wren has employed
it in some of his City churches. What he adopted was the second: he
vaulted the nave with a row of four domes, the choir with a row of three.
Thus, it might be thought, with seven domes leading up to a central dome,
Wren had secured harmony and success. It is not so. Nothing can be more
distressing to the eye than to follow the up and down line of the little
domes till it suddenly plunges into the central abyss. The only tolerable
form of vault in connection with a central dome is the tunnel vault, as
it is employed in St. Peter’s, Rome; or, still better, in S. Annunziata,
Genoa. Such a tunnel vault, however, should start direct from the
cornice, and not, as at St. Paul’s, from a meaningless attic interposed
between cornice and vault.
[Illustration: CHOIR.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account