English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised EditionBond, Francis
History
English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised Edition
Bond, Francis
Cathedrals -- England; Cathedrals -- Wales
Again, building on a virgin site, Elias de Dereham did what all great
builders have always wished to do—he made his building symmetrical. It is
the fashion to contrast the symmetry of Greek with the picturesqueness
of Gothic architecture. The comparison may be carried too far. The
Erechtheium is as unsymmetrical and picturesque as any Gothic building.
The great cathedrals of northern France, and Salisbury and Exeter,
are quite classical in their symmetry. But they are not pedantic in
their symmetry. Because nave balances choir, the north transept the
south transept, and the north-east transept the south-east transept,
the builder was not so foolish as to construct on the south a big
porch to balance that on the north side of the nave. Instead of that,
he built to the south an octagonal chapter-house, and this he placed
unsymmetrically—_i.e._, picturesquely—because, so placed, it was more
to the convenience of those who would have to use it. In other words, he
did not purposefully aim at the picturesque and the irregular. Gothic
cathedrals are picturesque, either of accident, as at Canterbury, owing
to the casual collocation of work of different design in the course of
several centuries, or because the different parts of the cathedral, being
intended for different functions, have been designed different in plan,
in dimensions, and in details. The latter is the case with Salisbury.
Two chief types of cathedral plan were at the architect’s disposal:
what we may call the York type, and the Wells type. In the latter,
the cathedral continues at its fullest height from the western doors
to the far east of the sanctuary, then the retro-choir or ante-chapel
(sometimes divided into Saint’s chapel and processional path or
ambulatory) is roofed at a far lower height, and east of them is a Lady
chapel, similarly on a low level. And, of course, as the upper wall of
the east end of the sanctuary requires to be supported, arches have to
be built beneath it opening from the sanctuary into the retro-choir.
The plan is a beautiful one—it is our English equivalent for the French
‘chevet.’ Externally, the different portions of the eastern limb tell
distinctly the purposes for which they are built: standing to the east
of Winchester, or Wells, or Hereford, you say at once, “This building is
the Lady chapel; there is the processional path and probably the shrine
of the local saint, there is the east end of the sanctuary, and the
light from that east window at the early morning services streams down
on the high altar below.” Internally, too, the effect is delightful; the
upper story of the cathedral is of course really greatly curtailed in
length, but the cathedral is not shortened to the eye: the mysterious
vistas through the east arches of the cathedral more than restore the
height lost above; the glimpses of Lady chapel behind ambulatory, and
ambulatory behind Saints’ chapel, as seen from far west in the nave,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account