English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised EditionBond, Francis
History
English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised Edition
Bond, Francis
Cathedrals -- England; Cathedrals -- Wales
Only one criticism suggests itself before we leave Salisbury cathedral
as seen from the north-east. Are not the voids in excess—two windows in
the aisles and three in the clerestory, where one would produce a much
more monumental and solid effect? Such single windows, filled with the
opaque grisaille glass of the period, would have subdued the glare of the
interior. But I have not the slightest doubt that the critics of the day
infinitely preferred the uniform good lighting of Salisbury to the “dim,
religious light” of Lincoln and its darksome corners and recesses. In
Salisbury there is not a quiet spot anywhere where you can pray in peace;
the blinding light pursues you everywhere. But good people in those days
liked a cheerful church—full of light, sparkling with stained glass,
brilliant with gilding and paint: religious gloom had not yet become
fashionable; it did not come in till the time of the Puritans. In every
respect except the fenestration, in Salisbury, as in Lincoln Minster,
internal seems to have been subordinated to external effect.
The interior is, indeed, very fine. It could hardly help being fine; a
nave so spacious and so proportioned could under no circumstances be a
failure. It is immensely high, and is long in proportion. The proportion
of height to span (2½ to 1) is better than in most English churches. The
harmony of the design—practically the same from east to west, and from
north to south—is unique in England, and is most impressive. The charming
way, too, in which the architect has contrived that we should have a
vista of another miniature church in the Lady chapel—a cathedral within
a cathedral—is worthy of all commendation. But, as in Lincoln nave, to
the eye every support is alarmingly insufficient for the work it has to
do; the piers are too tall and slender, the walls too thin, and pierced
with too many openings. The triforium is a most unfortunate design: in
harmony neither with the arcade below, nor with the clerestory above;
its outer arches ugly in themselves and discordant with every other arch
in the church; nor could it be expected that its dark marble shafts would
tell against a dark background—black on black. Add to this the dreadfully
new look of everything—partly due to the very perfection of the masonry,
partly because Scott has been here—and the overpowering glare: one almost
feels as if one were in the Crystal Palace. Of the west front it is as
well to say nothing; it would take pages to contain the unkind things
that have been said about it.
The Cathedral Church of St. Mary, Southwell.
[Illustration: FROM NORTH-WEST.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account