English Dialects From the Eighth Century to the Present DaySkeat, Walter W. (Walter William)
History
English Dialects From the Eighth Century to the Present Day
Skeat, Walter W. (Walter William)
English language -- Dialects
It is not long since a great parade was made of our borrowings from
"Celtic"; it was very easy to give a wild guess that an obscure word
was "Celtic"; and the hardihood of the guesser was often made to take
the place of evidence. The fact is that there is no such language as
"Celtic"; it is the name of a group of languages, including "British"
or Welsh, Cornish, Breton, Manx, Gaelic, and Irish; and it is now
incumbent on the etymologist to cite the exact forms in one or more of
these on which he relies, so as to adduce some semblance of proof. The
result has been an extraordinary shrinkage in the number of alleged
Celtic words. The number, in fact, is extremely small, except in
special cases. Thus we may expect to find a few Welsh words in the
dialects of Cheshire, Shropshire, or Herefordshire, on the Welsh
border; and a certain proportion of Gaelic words in Lowland Scotch;
though we have no reliable lists of these, and it is remarkable that
such words have usually been borrowed at no very early date, and
sometimes quite recently. The legacy of words bequeathed to us by the
ancient Britons is surprisingly small; indeed, it is very difficult
to point to many clear cases. The question is considered in my
_Principles of English Etymology, Series I_, pp. 443-452, to which I
may refer the reader; and a list of words of (probably) Celtic origin
is given in my larger _Etymological Dictionary_, ed. 1910, p. 765. It
is also explained, in my _Primer of English Etymology_ that, in the
fifth century, the time of Hengist's invasion, "the common language
of the more educated classes among the British was Latin, which was
in use as a literary language and as the language of the British
Christian Church. Hence, the Low German tribes [of invaders] found
no great necessity for learning ancient British; and this explains
the fact, which would otherwise be extraordinary, that modern English
contains but a very small Celtic element." Of the Celts that remained
within the English pale, it is certain that, in a very short time,
they accepted the necessity of learning Anglian or Saxon, and lost
their previous language altogether. Hence, in many dialects, as
for example, in the East Midland district, the amount of words of
"British" origin is practically _nil_. For further remarks on this
subject, see Chapter V of _Anglo-Saxon Britain_, by Grant Allen,
London, n.d.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account