Error's chains : $b How forged and broken : A comparative history of the national, social and religious errors that mankind has fallen into and practised from the creation down to the present time.Dobbins, Frank S. (Frank Stockton)
Religion
Error's chains : $b How forged and broken : A comparative history of the national, social and religious errors that mankind has fallen into and practised from the creation down to the present time.
Dobbins, Frank S. (Frank Stockton)
Idols and images -- Worship; Mythology; Religions
“Confucianism speaks to the _moral_ nature. It discourses on
virtue and vice, and the duty of compliance with law and the dictates
of conscience. Its worship rests on this basis. The religious
veneration paid to ancestors--for that is the worship of this
system--is founded on the duty of filial piety. The moral sense of the
Chinese is offended if they are called on to resign this custom.
“Taoism is _materialistic_. Its notion of the soul is of something
physical, a purer form of matter. The soul it supposes to gain
immortality by a physical discipline, a sort of chemical process, which
transmutes it into a more ethereal essence, and prepares it for being
transferred to the regions of immortality. The gods of Taoism are also
very much what might be expected in a system which has such notions
as these of the soul. It looks upon the stars as divine. It deifies
hermits and physicians, magicians and seekers after the philosopher’s
stone and the plant of immortality.
“Buddhism is different from both. It is _metaphysical_. It appeals
to the imagination, and deals in subtle argument. It says that the
world of the senses is altogether unreal, and upholds this proposition
by the most elaborate proofs. Its gods are personified ideas. It
denies matter entirely, and concerns itself only with ideas. Most of
the personages adored by the Buddhists are known to be nothing but
fictitious impersonations of some of these ideas. The Buddhist worship
is not reverence paid to beings believed to be actually existing; it
is a homage rendered to ideas, and it is only supposed to be reflex in
its effects. Their worship is useful as a discipline, but not effectual
as prayer. The Buddhist, if he can obtain abstraction of mind from the
world in any other mode, need not pray or worship at all.
“These three systems, occupying the three corners of a triangle--the
moral, the metaphysical and the material--are supplemental to each
other, and are able to co-exist without being mutually destructive.
They rest each on a basis of its own, and address themselves each to
different parts of man’s nature. It was because Confucianism ‘knew
God, but did not honor Him as God,’ that the way was left open for a
polytheism like that of the Buddhists. In the old books of China, God
is spoken of as the Supreme Ruler. He is represented as exercising over
mankind an infinitely just and beneficent providence. But the duty of
prayer is not enjoined. No worship of God by the people is permitted.
It was only by the emperor acting vicariously for the people that the
Deity was adored in that country. The system of Confucius, wanting
this, was more a morality than a religion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account