Essay on the Theory of the EarthCuvier, Georges, baron
Science
Essay on the Theory of the Earth
Cuvier, Georges, baron
Geology; Paleontology
The real eclipses, recorded by Confucius in his Chronicle of the
kingdom of Lou, commence only 1400 years after this, in the 776th
before Christ, and scarcely half a century earlier than those of the
Chaldeans related by Ptolemy. So true is it, that the nations which
escaped at the same time from the general catastrophe, also arrived
about the same period, when their circumstances have been similar,
at the same degree of civilization. Now, it might be thought, from
the identity of the names of the Chinese astronomers in different
reigns (they appear, according to the Chou-king, to have all been
named _Hi_ and _Ho_), that, at this remote epoch, their profession
was hereditary in China, as it was in India, Egypt, and Babylon.
The only Chinese observation of any antiquity, which has nothing in
itself to prove its want of authenticity, is that of the shadow made
by _Tcheou-kong_ about 1100 years before Christ; and even it is far
from being correct[211].
Hence our readers may conclude, that the inferences drawn from the
alleged perfection of astronomical science among ancient nations, is
not more conclusive in favour of the excessive antiquity of those
nations, than the testimonies which they have adduced in reference to
themselves.
But had this astronomy been more perfect, what would it prove?
Has the progress been calculated which this science ought to make
among nations who were not in any degree in possession of others;
to whom the serenity of the sky, the necessities of the pastoral or
agricultural life, and their superstitious ideas, would render the
stars an object of general attention; where colleges, or societies
of the most respectable men among them, were charged with keeping a
register of interesting phenomena, and transmitting their memory; and
where, from the hereditary nature of the profession, the children
were brought up from the cradle in the knowledge of facts ascertained
by their parents? Supposing that, among the numerous individuals of
whom the cultivation of astronomy was the sole occupation, there
should happen to be one or two possessed of extraordinary talents
for geometry, all the knowledge acquired by these nations might be
attained in a few centuries.
Since the time of the Chaldeans, real astronomy has only had two
eras, that of the Alexandrian school, which lasted 400 years, and
that of our own times, which has not existed so long. The learned
period of the Arabians scarcely added any thing to it; and the other
ages have been mere blanks with regard to it. Three hundred years did
not intervene between Copernicus and the author of the _Mecanique
Céleste_; and can it be believed that the Indians required thousands
of years to arrive at their crude theories?
_The Astronomical Monuments left by the Ancients do not bear the
excessively remote dates which have been attributed to them._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account