Essays in medical sociology, Volume 1 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 1 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
_Trade in Women_
It is necessary to define clearly the practical form of evil which is
now under consideration, and to the effects of which the consciences
of men and women must be roused. Ordinary immorality is not the
demoralization of the slums--that horrible result of monopoly and
speculation in land, where human beings are herded together like
pigs--a condition into which the bargains of trade hardly enter.
Neither is it the practice of free lust--a practice where unlimited
liberty is claimed by both men and women to indulge the impulses
of sexual caprice. Ordinary immorality is the distinct, deliberate
application to women of the trading system of money values governed
by unlimited competition. In this system activity, opportunity, and
cleverness carry the day; conscientiousness and spiritual aspiration
are out of place; innocence and ignorance constitute weakness, and, of
course, go to the wall.
Ordinary immorality or fornication, assuming the female body to be an
article of merchandise, necessarily subjects this merchandise to those
fluctuations of the market, those variations in demand and supply, and
that tyranny of capital over labour which destroy freedom of contract.
It may be urged that women ‘consent’ to be purchased, and that
therefore there is a radical difference between the purchase of the
bodies of men and women, which the anti-slavery movement has pronounced
illegal, and the purchase of women by men which we are now considering.
The sophistry of such evasion will be apparent if the question of
‘consent’ and the specious hypocrisy generally involved in freedom of
contract be closely examined. Freedom of contract can only take place
between those who in certain essential particulars are equals. The
parties to any contract must be so far equals in intelligence, that
they can equally understand any risks that may be run, and clearly
foresee the probable results of the bargain; and they must be so far
equals in social position, that neither party is compelled by the
pressure of circumstances or the fear of want, to accept conditions
which are unjust or unwise. No freedom of contract is possible where
this degree of intellectual and practical equality does not exist.
Freedom implies responsibility. There is no freedom if both parties
are not free. Any insistence upon consent to a bargain ignorantly
or forcibly made is fraud. It is fraud darkened by varying degrees
of cruelty, proportioned to the superiority of intelligence and
independence possessed by the stronger party in the bargain.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account