Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
The moral distinction between heroism shown when suffering is
witnessed for the purpose of aiding the sufferer and that evinced for
the selfish desire of individual gain or excitement, was strikingly
exhibited by a German nurse whom we sent on to the army during the
Civil War in America. This frail-looking woman drifted on to the front,
and, after the Battle of Gettysburg, donning a pair of man’s boots,
wading in pools of blood and mud, spent two days and nights on the
field of slaughter, drawing out still breathing bodies from the heaps
of slain, binding up wounds, giving a draught of water, placing a rough
pillow under the head, in an unselfish enthusiasm that knew neither
hunger nor fatigue. The ghastly wounds, the blood, the shrieks and
groans of that horrid scene served but as fuel to the fire of humanity
that consumed her.
_The Effect on Teachers or Practitioners of Medicine._--In considering
the subject of experimentation, reason requires that we realize the
necessary distinction between the methods employed in training students
for a practical profession and the exceptional position of the few
geniuses who possess the rare combination of qualities essential to
scientific investigation. In calling attention to this distinction we
do not condone torture, for this can be proved to be unscientific. But
it emphasizes a growing and mischievous evil of the present day when
numbers of ordinary teachers of physiology, whose gifts are limited and
whose especial business is to instruct students in the knowledge which
has been attained, consider themselves capable of original scientific
research, or attempt to repeat before either students or popular
audiences so-called demonstrations on living creatures.
The showy plan of experimenting on animals is undoubtedly a great
temptation to teachers. Such practice readily gains the gratifying
applause of inexperienced learners, who are misled by an appearance of
conclusiveness in the lectures, which they are quite incompetent to
gauge. But the influence thus exercised is a harmful one, diverting the
mind from right methods of study.
The temptation to make a display before imperfectly informed persons is
too great. If the profession is to advance in popular esteem, it will
recognise that the unfeeling destruction of living creatures, even the
pithing of a frog or the dissection of the salivary glands of a living
mouse, is a false method of forming the minds of students, which should
be entirely abandoned.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account