Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
The various ethical dangers resulting from conscienceless or irrational
experiments on animals demand much more serious consideration by the
profession than has hitherto been given to them. In the opinion of an
increasing number of intelligent physicians, a vast amount of what is
now presumptuously called research--experiments disguised under learned
names, but which are really the irrational mutilating and diseasing of
sentient living creatures--are no more _scientific_ research than is
the gratification of a child’s curiosity when it sticks a pin with a
thread through a cockchafer, to see how long it will fly and how loud
it will buzz. The child, when punished for its thoughtless cruelty,
might remonstrate in learned terms that it should not be restrained,
for it was investigating the vital endurance of the _Melolontha
vulgaris_ and the acoustic properties of its wing-covers, under
interesting and abnormal conditions.
A large proportion of what is simply conscienceless curiosity, often
starting from more or less frivolous tentative diversions of the
laboratory, though now by courtesy named research, is no more valuable
than the child’s spinning of the cockchafer, and should be as sharply
checked.
The genesis of discovery in biology, with its necessary relations to
therapeutics, has yet to be written. Extending experience is more and
more clearly showing us, as a practical fact, that whilst observation
and rational--_i.e._, humanely limited--experiment are legitimate
and noble efforts for the attainment of improved medicine, cruel
and merely curious experiment, condemned by our moral faculties, are
misleading and mischievous.
Men like Professor Henschel, of Upsala, and Professor Pettenkofer, of
Munich, warn our eager young investigators against drawing conclusions
as to human beings from experiments made on animals.
We find, as a matter of fact, that all the _permanent_ advances of
medicine have been gained whilst pursuing rational and righteous
methods, whilst all the fiascoes of supposed discovery have resulted
through departing from them.
Anæsthetics, antiseptics, and sanitation are not the result of cruel
experimentation.
_Danger of Inoculation._--The most serious fallacy arising from
erroneous methods of biological research is the practice of vitiating
human blood by the introduction of the diseased products of animals.
This dangerous method, which threatens to undermine national health,
is the necessary outcome of diseasing animals on the plea of seeking
remedies for human disease.
The intellectual fallacy involved in this practice will be considered
later; but its ethical character as affecting conscience must here be
noted, as it is this line of research which is productive of the most
extended form of cruelty to the lower animals--viz., _slow_ torture.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account