Essays In Pastoral MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
Essays In Pastoral Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
First aid in illness and injury; Medicine
As regards diphtheria, the chief causes of the spread of this disease
are mistaken diagnosis, imperfect isolation, incomplete disinfection,
and, paradoxical though it may seem, a lack of susceptibility to the
disease in a large number of children.
Many physicians are still under the grave error that diphtheria can
always be recognised without the aid of the microscope, and that
membranous croup commonly kills. All scientific writers upon
diphtheria agree that it is caused by the Klebs-Loeffler bacillus.
They also hold that there is a disease called membranous croup, as
distinct from diphtheria as typhoid is, but that membranous croup is a
comparatively harmless and non-contagious disease. Two per centum is a
liberal mortality in membranous croup, yet a certain class of
physicians are constantly reporting deaths from this disease. In a
series of 286 cases (not deaths) diagnosed as membranous croup by
physicians of New York {188} City a few years ago, Park found the
diphtheria bacillus in 229, or 80 per centum. I have never examined
the throat of a child dead from so-called membranous croup in which I
did not find the diphtheria bacillus. This is the experience of almost
every bacteriologist who has had to do with diphtheria. Some men
report deaths from diphtheria as thrush! These deaths might just as
truthfully be attributed to the wearing of linen collars.
On the other hand, according to Baginsky of Berlin, Martin of Paris,
Park of New York, and Morse of Boston, from 20 to 50 per centum of the
cases admitted even to diphtheria hospitals have not diphtheria at
all. Bacteriologists find that about 35 per centum of the cases
reported by physicians to be diphtheria are really nothing but
tonsilitis or pharyngitis, with now and then a case of membranous
croup. Without a bacteriological diagnosis, therefore, 35 families in
each 100 quarantined (where quarantine laws exist) are unjustly
quarantined and subjected to the trouble and expense of useless
disinfection. The suffering this can cause to a poor family, whose
small business is often ruined by quarantine, is a matter for very
serious consideration. Again, no matter what experience a physician
may have had, he can not in many cases differentiate diphtheria in its
early stages, or in children of good resisting power, from
comparatively harmless throat affections. The extraordinary resisting
power against diphtheria shown by some children and adults has been
described by Wassermann (_Zeitschrift f. Hyg._, 19 B., 3 H.). He found
one series of 17 children, from one and a half to eleven years of age,
and 34 adults, in which 11 children and 28 adults were not only immune
to diphtheria, but some of them had enough antitoxin in their blood to
neutralise a tenfold fatal dose of diphtheria toxin. This explains
many mysterious outbreaks of diphtheria: such immune persons are
infected and they carry about the disease unconsciously because they
are not ill themselves.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account