Essays In Pastoral MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
Essays In Pastoral Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
First aid in illness and injury; Medicine
As a matter of fact, prejudice is much more likely to be against the
supposed criminal than in his favour. While it is often declared that
too many persons, who have done at least material wrong, are allowed
to escape deserved punishment, as our knowledge of mental diseases
increases there is more and more of a tendency on the part of experts
to recognise that for many apparently voluntary actions men have only
a modicum of responsibility. Responsibility is, after all, not the
same in all men, but modified very much by the character of the
individual, by his environment and by the {302} motives which have
come to be the well-springs of his actions. No two men are equal in
their responsibility when there is question of certain temptations to
do wrong. Some men find it perfectly easy to resist allurements to
dishonesty which others can not resist. Some men are perfectly free as
regards their attitude towards indulgence in spirituous liquors.
Others find it almost impossible to resist their cravings in this
direction. One might go through the list of passionate actions and
find this true with regard to every one of them. If this must be
admitted with regard to men who are considered perfectly sane and
responsible, how much more so does it become true of those who are
already somewhat mentally unbalanced?
Unfortunately, the tendency to judge harshly, rather than mercifully,
still continues to be one main reason for the infliction of punishment
where often it is not deserved. Above all the clergyman must be a
leader in this tendency to mercy, and his influence should be felt in
popular education in this regard. It only too often happens that
clergymen are found to be strenuous upholders of the opinion that
right is simply right and wrong, wrong, and that a man who knows the
difference between right and wrong must be considered as responsible
for his actions, no matter what modifying circumstances or mental
conditions may enter into the problem of the decision as to his
responsibility. If the clergyman would but realise how difficult in
any individual case must be such a decision, and how much must be
known with regard to the previous character of the individual, then a
great beginning for the modification of the present over-severe modes
of thought will have been made.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account